A recommendation for "The Lord of the Beans" - a VeggieTales parody/pastiche of a more influential film series, with a message. It includes Sporks - monsters that are half-spoon, half-fork - the writing on the bean (on one side) says: "If you can read this, you are too close" - and the Bilbo equivalent says that he feels like "chocolate spread that's been spread over too much ham."
They must have had so much fun writing it! It's about the only thing that has distracted my son from Doctor Who in the last few weeks.
I've also now finished all the Alex Rider books - Stormbreaker, Point Blanc, Skeleton Key, Eagle Strike, Scorpia and Ark Angel - by Anthony Horowitz. They are targeted at children a few years older than mine. This isn't a bad idea, as it's hard to find things that particularly young teenage boys will read - but I foresee the necessity of explaining a few words to my children as they read the books.
The stories are somewhat formulaic, though exciting nonetheless. Alex Rider is a thirteen/fourteen year old orphan who reluctantly finds himself working as a spy for MI6. The James Bond cliches are present - the gadget inventor (Smithers), the psychopathic baddie who finds some reason to "monologue" to Alex towards the end of the book, death-defying stunts, the henchmen with striking appearances. But as James Bond moves back to his somewhat darker Ian Fleming identity in "Casino Royale", Alex Rider comes across as the victim of his adventures as much as the hero, bearing emotional scars as well as physical ones from a very intense few months. The badness of the villains is made very clear - their disregard for the lives of everyone who might get in their way - and Alex is not given the opportunity to kill people "in cold blood" - though he does end up killing people in self-defence.
A good series, which kept me turning pages and buying the next book until I'd finished.
Data is not information. Information is not knowledge. Knowledge is not wisdom. Wisdom is not truth. Truth is not life.
Sunday, September 03, 2006
Tuesday, August 29, 2006
Just a quick link ....
... to an interview with philosopher Del Ratzsch. I have a lot of sympathy with much of what he says about Evolutionism/Creationism/ID.
This interview also provided more motivation for going to read books by Alvin Plantinga. But that, along with more interesting posts, will have to wait.
It seems to me that some of the design issues are too important to let heat trump light, which has undeniably been part of the story to this point, and that the vitriol from both sides is an index of that importance. There are few matters that go deeper than the nature of human cognition, the nature of the reality we inhabit, naturalism/theism questions, and so forth. So I have wanted to try to wrestle some of those issues to the ground. I don't think I've completely managed that at this point, but that is hardly a unique position - at least as I see it, no one else has either. And besides all that, I just find the issues fascinating.(HT Telic Thoughts)
This interview also provided more motivation for going to read books by Alvin Plantinga. But that, along with more interesting posts, will have to wait.
Wednesday, August 16, 2006
Tim Keller
The Carey Family Conference has been one of the highlights of our family year for the last six years or thereabouts. We have good friends there, and it's an environment in which even small children can just spend the day running around with one another, whilst parents can get stuck into serious conversations.
It was great to catch up with friends there, but one of the most significant things about the Carey Family Conference for me this year was in a couple of meetings. I met Mark Troughton, who works at York Evangelical Church, and on the way home we stayed with friends in Bedford, so I was able to renew an old acquaintance with Ray Evans, who works at Grace Community Church (formerly Kempston Evangelical Church). Both churches are thinking hard about how Christianity ought to be presented in today's world. Both leaders pointed me in the direction of some studies on these issues, linked with the central part of the book of Acts, written by Tim Keller, of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York. Here is a link to the first of these papers.
These are full of thought-provoking and challenging material. For example, on music:
A list of resources by Tim Keller, including links to the four parts of this paper, can be found here.
It was great to catch up with friends there, but one of the most significant things about the Carey Family Conference for me this year was in a couple of meetings. I met Mark Troughton, who works at York Evangelical Church, and on the way home we stayed with friends in Bedford, so I was able to renew an old acquaintance with Ray Evans, who works at Grace Community Church (formerly Kempston Evangelical Church). Both churches are thinking hard about how Christianity ought to be presented in today's world. Both leaders pointed me in the direction of some studies on these issues, linked with the central part of the book of Acts, written by Tim Keller, of Redeemer Presbyterian Church in New York. Here is a link to the first of these papers.
These are full of thought-provoking and challenging material. For example, on music:
God commanded Israel to invite the nations to join in declaring his glory. Zion is to be the center of world-winning worship (Isaiah 2:2-4; 56:6-8). In Acts 2 and I Cor. 14:23ff we see non-believers attracted and disturbed by worship. We learn 1) nonbelievers are expected in worship, 2) non-believers must find worship challenging and comprehensible, not comfortable. If the Sunday service and sermon aim primarily at evangelism, it will bore the saints. If they aim primarily at education, they will bore and confuse unbelievers. If they aim at praising the God who saves by sheer grace they will both instruct the saints and challenge the sinners. Evangelistic worship is especially important for post-modern people for whom context is everything and who need to see how the gospel 'works' in people's lives. What does it take? 1) General principle--worship as if non-Christians are present before they really are, and they will be brought. 2) Specifics: a) inclusive quality of speaking and music, b) noble simplicity of language (not sentimental, austere, archaic, or colloquial), c) solve people's problems with the gospel.On being gospel-focused:
Unless you distinguish the gospel from both religion and irreligion–from both traditional moralism and liberal relativism–then newcomers in your services will automatically think you are simply calling them to be good and nice people. They will be bored. But when, as here in Acts 15, the gospel is communicated in its unique, counter-intuitive balance of truth and love, then listeners will be surprised. Most people today try to place the church somewhere along a spectrum from "liberal" to "conservative"–from the relativistic to the moralistic. But when they see a church filled with people who insist on the truth, but without a shred of superiority or self-righteousness–this simply explodes their categories. To them, people who have the truth are not gracious, people who are gracious and accepting say "who knows what is the truth?" Christians are enormously bold to tell the truth, but without a shred of superiority, because you are sinner saved by grace. This balance of boldness and utter humility, truth and love–is not somewhere in the middle between legalistic fundamentalism and relativistic liberalism. It is actually off the charts.These are probably the most important things I have seen about how to "do church" since I read "Church - No Spectator Sport" by Eric Wright about 12 years ago.
A list of resources by Tim Keller, including links to the four parts of this paper, can be found here.
Monday, August 14, 2006
How did the Giraffe get its neck?
... and other Just-So stories ...
The Discovery Institute have a link to a paper written by Wolf-Ekkehard Lönnig on this issue, challenging (gasp!) Richard Dawkins and (gasp!gasp!) TalkOrigins.
They also have a link to an article called "A Mathematician's View of Evolution", written by Granville Sewell, a mathematician at the University of Texas El Paso. He says:
Neither of these papers were written by the "usual suspects".
The Discovery Institute have a link to a paper written by Wolf-Ekkehard Lönnig on this issue, challenging (gasp!) Richard Dawkins and (gasp!gasp!) TalkOrigins.
They also have a link to an article called "A Mathematician's View of Evolution", written by Granville Sewell, a mathematician at the University of Texas El Paso. He says:
When Dr. Behe was at the University of Texas El Paso in May of 1997 to give an invited talk, I told him that I thought he would find more support for his ideas in mathematics, physics and computer science departments than in his own field. I know a good many mathematicians, physicists and computer scientists who, like me, are appalled that Darwin's explanation for the development of life is so widely accepted in the life sciences.... something I have also said on various occasions in discussions about evolution, but without much support.
Neither of these papers were written by the "usual suspects".
Saturday, August 12, 2006
Damaris
The "Facing the Challenge" course, part of which I ran at the Carey Family Conference, plugged the "Damaris" website - a website which seeks to engage with the culture around us with a Christian worldview. For anybody who is as keen on Christian worldviews and Doctor Who as I am, here is a taster.
Wednesday, July 26, 2006
Monton continued
On the right is a link to a post I wrote about Monton's paper: "The Infinite Universe and Dembski's Design Inference." The Maiden commented:
Someone like Dave Heddle, perhaps, who also stopped by to comment on the original post, and pointed out that the currently prevailing model was that the universe was flat and (presumably) finite in mass.
Although it wasn't relevant to the paper under discussion, Steve made the point that
The point of all this being that Monton's paper doesn't constitute a refutation of Dembski's work if his assumption that the universe could be infinite, or have infinite mass, is wrong. There may be other refutations, but this wouldn't be one.
If I remember right, the critical density is something like one molecule of hydrogen per cubic meter. Now, imagine that universe-- one cubic meter with the equivalent of one hydrogen molecule of mass. That universe will never collapse. In fact, if the numbers are absolutely perfect that universe will be completely flat. If you double both the mass and the volume, the density stays the same. Double it. Triple it. The density won't change so long as each value goes up by the same figure, even if that figure is infinity. It should be easy to see then that it is possible to have an infinite universe with infinite mass but which never collapses.I wanted further consideration of this comment by others more qualified. I think that what the maiden says is true as far as it goes, but the prevailing understanding of the origin of the universe is that it appeared in the Big Bang. At this point, the universe wasn't "infinitely large" - in fact, it began expanding from an infinitesimally small point. If the mass of the universe were infinite, then the expansion would not have continued. I think the maiden is correct in terms of physics, but not in terms of cosmology, but I'd like somebody who is more up to speed to comment further.
Someone like Dave Heddle, perhaps, who also stopped by to comment on the original post, and pointed out that the currently prevailing model was that the universe was flat and (presumably) finite in mass.
Although it wasn't relevant to the paper under discussion, Steve made the point that
Dembski's work, such as his paper on searching large spaces, completely ignores the impact of natural selection on the probabilities involved. Hence his probability calculations are suspect.This isn't the case: Steve seems to have misunderstood what Dembski is talking about. Steve correctly observes that natural selection is not a chance process - which means that, since not designed, it is a "regularity". Dembski's thesis is that there is a limit to the amount of specified information that a regular process can generate. Steve's point seems to be simply that "natural selection does create specified information" - which simply contradicts Dembski with no supporting evidence.
The point of all this being that Monton's paper doesn't constitute a refutation of Dembski's work if his assumption that the universe could be infinite, or have infinite mass, is wrong. There may be other refutations, but this wouldn't be one.
"Stop and go with ... ?"
If you do a search on "Stop and go with mercy", you'll discover that this is a VeggieTales song ("On the Road with Bob and Larry", "Jonah") that features in various family households. Ours isn't exempt, since we have worked through "On the Road" on several car journeys.
Our youngest (5) is a little shaky on the words, though. This morning she's been singing "Stop and Go with Percy". I'm not sure who she thinks Percy is - perhaps somebody in the van with Bob and Larry, along with "all those children in the back"!
Our youngest (5) is a little shaky on the words, though. This morning she's been singing "Stop and Go with Percy". I'm not sure who she thinks Percy is - perhaps somebody in the van with Bob and Larry, along with "all those children in the back"!
Monday, July 24, 2006
More on modelling evolution
Imagine an environment which contains a variety of resources: we might imagine these as being carbon dioxide molecules, water molecules, visible light photons, and so on. The environment will probably contain a large number of these – though not uncountably large. And even using non-specialist datatypes, a 64 bit integer will allow counting up to 1018 – a 16 byte BCD number (“decimal” in Visual Basic) will count up to 1028! So it is possible to work with pretty large populations – remember that 22.4 dm3 of gas contains only 6x1023 molecules – and of course, the same datatypes are available to count instances of particular species.
Imagine in this environment a simple proto-organism – perhaps no more than a protein; perhaps as much as a simple cellular organism. The significant thing about this proto-organism is that it is the simplest reproducing organism. If the organism has access to (say) two molecules of carbon dioxide, two molecules of water and a photon of visible light, it will reproduce, becoming two copies of the organism, and outputting (let's say) one molecule of oxygen. There are now two copies of the organism, and the environment has gained one molecule of oxygen, but lost the required input molecules and energy. (We deduce from this that the organism consists of two carbon atoms, four hydrogen atoms, and four oxygen atoms ... but that's not important right now.)
As the population of this organism grows, the number of molecules of the resources in the environment decreases. It would be possible for the environment to be replenished with each step, or for a limited amount of a particular environmental resource to be available at each step.
Now, with a finite probability, the organism might mutate. Not just generally mutate, but significantly mutate. What I mean by a “significant mutation” is that it changes what it uses from the environment and what it returns to the environment when it reproduces. So an organism might use a molecule of oxygen instead of one of the molecules of carbon dioxide, and return a molecule of carbon dioxide when it reproduces. If this happens, we have a functionally different organism – which itself reproduces and affects the environment.
In my latest foray into Visual Basic, I started modelling this. It is possible to have mutation rates at very low levels (let's say one in 1010, for the sake of argument), so the population of an organism has to get to the sort of levels that most programs modelling evolution can't dream of before it is likely to mutate.
The number of exchanges with the environment (molecules used or returned) represent what I termed the "weight" of the organism. The higher the weight, the longer an organism takes to reproduce. If a resource in the environment is exhausted, the population of an organism that requires that resource to reproduce declines. If it is "limited" (by which, in my first attempt at modelling it, I suggested that more than 1% of the environmental resource is used in each step) the population of an organism that requires that resource won't grow.
I think this is a new approach to modelling evolution - and it is more concerned with large-scale changes in populations over time, rather than the evolution of new functionality. Indeed, this model assumes that new functionality can evolve (and that the proto-organism can appear in the first place), rather than seeking to demonstrate how this might happen, and on that basis looks at how populations might develop over time. "Tangled Nature", as developed by Henrik Jensen et al, looks at changes in large populations in this way, but I think the advantage of this approach is that it ought to be less computationally heavy but still able to yield interesting results.
Imagine in this environment a simple proto-organism – perhaps no more than a protein; perhaps as much as a simple cellular organism. The significant thing about this proto-organism is that it is the simplest reproducing organism. If the organism has access to (say) two molecules of carbon dioxide, two molecules of water and a photon of visible light, it will reproduce, becoming two copies of the organism, and outputting (let's say) one molecule of oxygen. There are now two copies of the organism, and the environment has gained one molecule of oxygen, but lost the required input molecules and energy. (We deduce from this that the organism consists of two carbon atoms, four hydrogen atoms, and four oxygen atoms ... but that's not important right now.)
As the population of this organism grows, the number of molecules of the resources in the environment decreases. It would be possible for the environment to be replenished with each step, or for a limited amount of a particular environmental resource to be available at each step.
Now, with a finite probability, the organism might mutate. Not just generally mutate, but significantly mutate. What I mean by a “significant mutation” is that it changes what it uses from the environment and what it returns to the environment when it reproduces. So an organism might use a molecule of oxygen instead of one of the molecules of carbon dioxide, and return a molecule of carbon dioxide when it reproduces. If this happens, we have a functionally different organism – which itself reproduces and affects the environment.
In my latest foray into Visual Basic, I started modelling this. It is possible to have mutation rates at very low levels (let's say one in 1010, for the sake of argument), so the population of an organism has to get to the sort of levels that most programs modelling evolution can't dream of before it is likely to mutate.
The number of exchanges with the environment (molecules used or returned) represent what I termed the "weight" of the organism. The higher the weight, the longer an organism takes to reproduce. If a resource in the environment is exhausted, the population of an organism that requires that resource to reproduce declines. If it is "limited" (by which, in my first attempt at modelling it, I suggested that more than 1% of the environmental resource is used in each step) the population of an organism that requires that resource won't grow.
I think this is a new approach to modelling evolution - and it is more concerned with large-scale changes in populations over time, rather than the evolution of new functionality. Indeed, this model assumes that new functionality can evolve (and that the proto-organism can appear in the first place), rather than seeking to demonstrate how this might happen, and on that basis looks at how populations might develop over time. "Tangled Nature", as developed by Henrik Jensen et al, looks at changes in large populations in this way, but I think the advantage of this approach is that it ought to be less computationally heavy but still able to yield interesting results.
Friday, July 21, 2006
Yesterday's "Times"
Matthew Parris argued that Israel needs to go "the extra mile" to settle the argument - that is, offer more than they have to for the sake of goodwill. I suspect that Israel would argue that, by voluntarily withdrawing from Palestinian territory earlier in the year, and offering more territory, it had already done that. It's also interesting that he, a non-Christian (although one who has shown a clear understanding of the nature of the Christian message), should be arguing that a non-Christian state should operate according to a Christian ethical standard.
Their weather correspondent argued that an immediate carbon tax on aviation ought to be introduced, because aviation fuel isn't taxed. This is being repeated so often, it has almost become a mantra. In the UK, Airline Passenger Duty is already imposed - there is no comparable tax on railway or sea travel. And yet, flying is still generally cheaper than surface transport. Furthermore, whilst rail attracts huge subsidies, the airlines raise their own capital and have to operate profitably. British Airways is approaching an operating margin of 10% - although this is high, and comparable with the low-cost airlines, the historical margins of airlines are much lower. The bottom line is that any extra tax can't come from airline profits, because they don't have enough. It would be passed straight onto the consumer.
This isn't arguing against such a tax, which may be an appropriate response to increasing carbon emissions. Some airlines already want to be part of the emissions trading schemes. But it is somewhat absurd that airlines are being penalised for their commercial success when so many people long for viable surface alternatives.
Their weather correspondent argued that an immediate carbon tax on aviation ought to be introduced, because aviation fuel isn't taxed. This is being repeated so often, it has almost become a mantra. In the UK, Airline Passenger Duty is already imposed - there is no comparable tax on railway or sea travel. And yet, flying is still generally cheaper than surface transport. Furthermore, whilst rail attracts huge subsidies, the airlines raise their own capital and have to operate profitably. British Airways is approaching an operating margin of 10% - although this is high, and comparable with the low-cost airlines, the historical margins of airlines are much lower. The bottom line is that any extra tax can't come from airline profits, because they don't have enough. It would be passed straight onto the consumer.
This isn't arguing against such a tax, which may be an appropriate response to increasing carbon emissions. Some airlines already want to be part of the emissions trading schemes. But it is somewhat absurd that airlines are being penalised for their commercial success when so many people long for viable surface alternatives.
Monday, July 17, 2006
What's wrong with Darwinism?
I found a link to this article, from the Royal Institute of Philosophy, on the ARN website. It should rattle a few cages, I guess!
Sunday, July 16, 2006
My Favourite Disney Films
We've just spent a weekend away - camping, for the first time as a family, though not self-catering - with one of the churches that we are members of. Malcolm Macgregor spoke. A good time was had by all, I believe.
Completely disconnected, here is a list of my five favourite Disney animations, in reverse order ...
5) Tarzan
An unusually good soundtrack (Phil Collins) - indeed, the only movie soundtrack I've ever bought, though I felt somewhat shortchanged afterwards. Particularly strong in the first half, where Tarzan is struggling with his identity, and his adopted mother is seeking to protect him.
4) Finding Nemo
Probably the most beautiful animation ever, in my opinion.
3) The Incredibles
Very clever film. Does anybody not love it?
2) Lilo and Stitch
Unexpected choice. Lovely animation, subtle but knowing plot, with references to all sorts of other films, and various issues flagged in a low-key way (genetic engineering, obsessive disorders for example).
1) The Emperor's New Groove
Unexpected choice, I imagine, but it is enjoyable and fun. A brilliant script, good characters - both the sympathetic "good guys" and the suitably villainous "bad guy" - and animation that is stylistically "retro". The restaurant scene is particularly clever, as is the chase finale. "I've turned into a cow. May I be excused?". More quotes here.
Strongly biased towards recent releases, I notice. We didn't see many films when I was growing up, and when I compare these films with those I've seen since, I just think these are stronger. Probably my favourite older one is "Jungle Book".
Disney films are, of course, generally derided by serious critics. I suppose the problem with Disney isn't in the themes it addresses - which are universal - identity, relations with parents and so on. It's that it seems to "cheapen" them, by making them commercial. But then, isn't that what every writer or film director is seeking to do, I wonder?
Completely disconnected, here is a list of my five favourite Disney animations, in reverse order ...
5) Tarzan
An unusually good soundtrack (Phil Collins) - indeed, the only movie soundtrack I've ever bought, though I felt somewhat shortchanged afterwards. Particularly strong in the first half, where Tarzan is struggling with his identity, and his adopted mother is seeking to protect him.
4) Finding Nemo
Probably the most beautiful animation ever, in my opinion.
3) The Incredibles
Very clever film. Does anybody not love it?
2) Lilo and Stitch
Unexpected choice. Lovely animation, subtle but knowing plot, with references to all sorts of other films, and various issues flagged in a low-key way (genetic engineering, obsessive disorders for example).
1) The Emperor's New Groove
Unexpected choice, I imagine, but it is enjoyable and fun. A brilliant script, good characters - both the sympathetic "good guys" and the suitably villainous "bad guy" - and animation that is stylistically "retro". The restaurant scene is particularly clever, as is the chase finale. "I've turned into a cow. May I be excused?". More quotes here.
Strongly biased towards recent releases, I notice. We didn't see many films when I was growing up, and when I compare these films with those I've seen since, I just think these are stronger. Probably my favourite older one is "Jungle Book".
Disney films are, of course, generally derided by serious critics. I suppose the problem with Disney isn't in the themes it addresses - which are universal - identity, relations with parents and so on. It's that it seems to "cheapen" them, by making them commercial. But then, isn't that what every writer or film director is seeking to do, I wonder?
Tuesday, July 11, 2006
The pain of divorce ...
... isn't only felt by women - though Miss Mellifluous writes not only movingly but instructively. (HT Amanda). That's about the third time in the last few months that Genesis 15 has been brought to my attention.
A male acquaintance was recently told by his wife that she wants a divorce. I report this not to embarrass anyone or prejudice any legal process - neither party knows about this blog - but because it is typical of what is happening today. There are no other adults involved, apparently, but they do have children. She is not interested in counselling - she says she is doing this "for herself" - but, as my acquaintance points out, the whole point about the wedding vows is that you forego your future right to do things primarily "for yourself". She has said she doesn't want him to come back home. To what is his home as well, it should be pointed out - though the solicitor said that in such cases, "possession is nine tenths of the law".
To add financial insult to injury, in the divorce papers, she has claimed a large proportion of their assets - presumably because she expects custody of the children - and the legal advice my acquaintance has received is she can expect to get most of them. So she has chosen to walk away from a promise that she freely gave, and she can expect to benefit substantially from this.
It is frustration with this, and the helplessness that many men feel in the face of the family law system, that has led to the establishing of groups like Fathers 4 Justice. They may not be changing the world, but they are at least showing the world their frustration, and highlighting the unreasonableness of the system.
A male acquaintance was recently told by his wife that she wants a divorce. I report this not to embarrass anyone or prejudice any legal process - neither party knows about this blog - but because it is typical of what is happening today. There are no other adults involved, apparently, but they do have children. She is not interested in counselling - she says she is doing this "for herself" - but, as my acquaintance points out, the whole point about the wedding vows is that you forego your future right to do things primarily "for yourself". She has said she doesn't want him to come back home. To what is his home as well, it should be pointed out - though the solicitor said that in such cases, "possession is nine tenths of the law".
To add financial insult to injury, in the divorce papers, she has claimed a large proportion of their assets - presumably because she expects custody of the children - and the legal advice my acquaintance has received is she can expect to get most of them. So she has chosen to walk away from a promise that she freely gave, and she can expect to benefit substantially from this.
It is frustration with this, and the helplessness that many men feel in the face of the family law system, that has led to the establishing of groups like Fathers 4 Justice. They may not be changing the world, but they are at least showing the world their frustration, and highlighting the unreasonableness of the system.
Wednesday, July 05, 2006
Historical fiction
More posts to come soon, honest! (Well, maybe not - I am haemorraging time at the moment, it seems).
I've just read two substantial works of historical fiction - or at least, the second is nearly finished - English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale, and Human Traces, by Sebastian Faulks. Both were bought me as presents - I doubt I'd have picked them up otherwise. However, they have both been rewarding and challenging reads.
I had always assumed that Tolkein's task, in creating an entire universe from scratch, was one of the most challenging for a novelist. However, in both these cases, the work that has been done by the author to:
a) bed their characters in a universe that is full of real (that is, not fictional) people, real locations and real events,
b) make their stories significant but
c) allow them to touch lightly enough on the world to not change history,
is quite remarkable. Both books make for disturbing reading - I would not expect to see either on GCSE reading lists in the near future.
Faulks' description of the treatment of mentally ill at the end of the 19th century is particularly powerful, and he does a great deal to try and communicate the nature of schizophrenia - both from the perspective of the sufferer, and those who are close to it.
At some stage, I'd like to talk through some of the ideas that Faulks puts forward, in the mouth of one of his principal characters, Thomas Midwinter, who judging from his reception and the perspective of the writing, I think Faulks is using as a mouthpiece for some of his own thoughts on what it means to be human. For now, it is worth noting that some very thoughtful and articulate arguments are set forth, and the ideas lie in the synthesis of different branches of knowledge, rather than through a kind of reductionist insight.
I've just read two substantial works of historical fiction - or at least, the second is nearly finished - English Passengers, by Matthew Kneale, and Human Traces, by Sebastian Faulks. Both were bought me as presents - I doubt I'd have picked them up otherwise. However, they have both been rewarding and challenging reads.
I had always assumed that Tolkein's task, in creating an entire universe from scratch, was one of the most challenging for a novelist. However, in both these cases, the work that has been done by the author to:
a) bed their characters in a universe that is full of real (that is, not fictional) people, real locations and real events,
b) make their stories significant but
c) allow them to touch lightly enough on the world to not change history,
is quite remarkable. Both books make for disturbing reading - I would not expect to see either on GCSE reading lists in the near future.
Faulks' description of the treatment of mentally ill at the end of the 19th century is particularly powerful, and he does a great deal to try and communicate the nature of schizophrenia - both from the perspective of the sufferer, and those who are close to it.
At some stage, I'd like to talk through some of the ideas that Faulks puts forward, in the mouth of one of his principal characters, Thomas Midwinter, who judging from his reception and the perspective of the writing, I think Faulks is using as a mouthpiece for some of his own thoughts on what it means to be human. For now, it is worth noting that some very thoughtful and articulate arguments are set forth, and the ideas lie in the synthesis of different branches of knowledge, rather than through a kind of reductionist insight.
Monday, June 19, 2006
What does "gay" mean?
Last night, on Radio 4's Feedback programme, I discovered that in addition to it meaning "homosexual", the word "gay" is currently being used to mean "rubbish". The reason this featured on the programme was to discuss whether it was acceptable to use the word like this when it might be considered offensive to homosexuals.
At one stage, "gay" had an innocent role meaning: "cheery: bright and pleasant; promoting a feeling of cheer". It became a word meaning: "homosexual". I don't believe anybody was consulted about this redefinition. I agree that if people don't understand the way in which a word is being used it needs to be explained - jargon is always a barrier to communication - but words are no more owned by the homosexual community - or any other minority - than they are by anybody else.
One of the people interviewed wondered whether words describing other sections of the community had become terms of abuse, and how other groups might react to this. Well, two such words came to mind very quickly. The first is "liberal", and is now generally used to refer to somebody politically to the left of me - though this is low-key enough that few people would regard this as a term of abuse. However, the word "fundamentalist" is now almost universally regarded as a term of abuse. It originally meant somebody who aligned themselves with a publication called "The Fundamentals: A Testimony to the Truth" - but it is now used as a term meaning "somebody so far politically or religiously to the right of me that there is little point in debating with them".
I would have thought that critical thinking is of greater importance than the way in which language is used. People need to understand that choice of words evokes a particular reaction. Why do sections of the homosexual community object to using the word "gay" to mean "rubbish"? Is it because they want to maintain the association with the meaning "cheery: bright and pleasant"? So is their objection to the new use of the word any less arbitrary than the way in which they choose to use it? Why, for that matter, did "The Brights" choose that particular adjective to describe themselves, rather than (say) "The Dims", "The Electrodes" or "The Porches"?
As Humpty Dumpty said: "When I use a word, it means what I want it to mean; neither more, nor less."
At one stage, "gay" had an innocent role meaning: "cheery: bright and pleasant; promoting a feeling of cheer". It became a word meaning: "homosexual". I don't believe anybody was consulted about this redefinition. I agree that if people don't understand the way in which a word is being used it needs to be explained - jargon is always a barrier to communication - but words are no more owned by the homosexual community - or any other minority - than they are by anybody else.
One of the people interviewed wondered whether words describing other sections of the community had become terms of abuse, and how other groups might react to this. Well, two such words came to mind very quickly. The first is "liberal", and is now generally used to refer to somebody politically to the left of me - though this is low-key enough that few people would regard this as a term of abuse. However, the word "fundamentalist" is now almost universally regarded as a term of abuse. It originally meant somebody who aligned themselves with a publication called "The Fundamentals: A Testimony to the Truth" - but it is now used as a term meaning "somebody so far politically or religiously to the right of me that there is little point in debating with them".
I would have thought that critical thinking is of greater importance than the way in which language is used. People need to understand that choice of words evokes a particular reaction. Why do sections of the homosexual community object to using the word "gay" to mean "rubbish"? Is it because they want to maintain the association with the meaning "cheery: bright and pleasant"? So is their objection to the new use of the word any less arbitrary than the way in which they choose to use it? Why, for that matter, did "The Brights" choose that particular adjective to describe themselves, rather than (say) "The Dims", "The Electrodes" or "The Porches"?
As Humpty Dumpty said: "When I use a word, it means what I want it to mean; neither more, nor less."
Should faith be blind?
I have posted before about the different ways in which the word "faith" is used, quoting Francis Schaeffer on this issue at length.
People continue to use a kind of "postmodern" understanding of what faith means to try and say that Christians ought to regard their beliefs as something fundamentally irrational. Here is part of a letter published in Nature:
Look at the next two verses:
No, says John. Jesus did loads of other things, but the whole point of me writing these things down is so that people who haven't seen can still believe. My eyewitness testimony is reliable, he says.
So faith isn't supposed to be blind - lacking in evidence. Faith is supposed to be based on knowledge that has been supplied by eyewitnesses.
Furthermore, elsewhere in the Bible, writers make it clear that regardless of whether or not a person accepts the validity of these eyewitness accounts, there is still enough evidence for them to know that there is a God - in the Old Testament, it says that "the heavens declare the glory of God". In the New Testament, Paul the apostle writes in Romans 1 that even though God is invisible, the nature of the universe tells us about what he is like. When the Bible talks about faith, it is certainly confidence in something that isn't seen - but that doesn't mean that the sense in the Bible is that it is a leap in the dark.
The idea of religious belief being something fundamentally irrational derives not from the nature of Christianity, but from the way in which existentialism and postmodernism have invaded all areas of public discourse over the last 200 years.
People continue to use a kind of "postmodern" understanding of what faith means to try and say that Christians ought to regard their beliefs as something fundamentally irrational. Here is part of a letter published in Nature:
Your Editorial about the promotion of ID in schools and universities (Nature 434, 1053; 2005) asks us to persuade our students that science and faith do not compete, but for Christians this should always have been clear. In the Bible (John 20: 25−29), Thomas doubts that the man speaking to him is the resurrected Christ until Jesus reveals his wounds. Thomas then believes, but Jesus says: "Blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed".This section of John's gospel is often used in support of this claim, but by taking those two verses out of context, they are almost completely reversing the sense of what was originally written.
The Bible throughout teaches that faith is more valuable when expressed in the absence of evidence. For a Christian, when science is allowed to be neutral on the subject of God, science can only bolster faith.
Look at the next two verses:
Jesus did many other miraculous signs in the presence of his disciples, which are not recorded in this book. But these are written that you may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God, and that by believing you may have life in his name.Thomas saw and believed, and Jesus says that those who haven't seen and yet have still believed will be blessed. The question is: how are we who haven't seen supposed to know that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God? This would be an understandable question long before the postmodern era. Is this supposed to be blind faith? An irrational leap in the dark?
No, says John. Jesus did loads of other things, but the whole point of me writing these things down is so that people who haven't seen can still believe. My eyewitness testimony is reliable, he says.
So faith isn't supposed to be blind - lacking in evidence. Faith is supposed to be based on knowledge that has been supplied by eyewitnesses.
Furthermore, elsewhere in the Bible, writers make it clear that regardless of whether or not a person accepts the validity of these eyewitness accounts, there is still enough evidence for them to know that there is a God - in the Old Testament, it says that "the heavens declare the glory of God". In the New Testament, Paul the apostle writes in Romans 1 that even though God is invisible, the nature of the universe tells us about what he is like. When the Bible talks about faith, it is certainly confidence in something that isn't seen - but that doesn't mean that the sense in the Bible is that it is a leap in the dark.
The idea of religious belief being something fundamentally irrational derives not from the nature of Christianity, but from the way in which existentialism and postmodernism have invaded all areas of public discourse over the last 200 years.
Thursday, June 15, 2006
Junk DNA and the anti-design hypothesis
The charge against ID is that assuming something has purpose doesn't lead to useful science.
The countercharge (from me) is that assuming something doesn't have purpose doesn't lead to useful science.
I've started a new post because these ideas are very interesting, and deserve more visibility than they would get in comments of an existing post.
Looking at this in the context of non-coding DNA...
I was trying to remember back to Biology of Cells Part I (1986-7). I don't recall ever being taught much about non-coding DNA, other than the fact that there was lots of it - and I'm pretty sure that the phrase "junk DNA" goes back in my mind well over a decade.
I also looked in Alberts et al ("Molecular Biology of the Cell", 1983) to find out what he said, which was:
Even more significant is Goodenough ("Genetics", 3rd Edition, 1984). Again there is no reference to "junk DNA", but there are two short sections that relate to non-coding DNA. Firstly, in the context of considering the chromosome of a virus
So to conclude, I can't offer evidence on the basis of the information I have to hand that an anti-design hypothesis inhibited research. However, I have demonstrated that this non-coding DNA, despite its significance within a cell, was basically ignored at an undergraduate level as late as the mid-1980's. At best, this suggests that it was considered to have no biological significance; it was "not essential"; non-coding DNA was an "evolutionary relic". What would motivate people to investigate the significance of something when mainstream textbooks had dismissed it in those terms?
The countercharge (from me) is that assuming something doesn't have purpose doesn't lead to useful science.
I've started a new post because these ideas are very interesting, and deserve more visibility than they would get in comments of an existing post.
Looking at this in the context of non-coding DNA...
To demonstrate [that an anti-teleological approach restricted science], you'd need to show that this approach had caused people to reject valid evidence that certain DNA had function. Otherwise, all that you'd be demonstrating was that lack of function was indeed a valid null hypothesis, which people would happily move away from in the face of evidence.I don't think so. To demonstrate this, you have to show that having assumed that something had little or no purpose, people turned their faces away from it to areas that looked more promising. Had they assumed that it had purpose, they might have continued their investigations and discovered the purpose at an earlier stage.
I was trying to remember back to Biology of Cells Part I (1986-7). I don't recall ever being taught much about non-coding DNA, other than the fact that there was lots of it - and I'm pretty sure that the phrase "junk DNA" goes back in my mind well over a decade.
I also looked in Alberts et al ("Molecular Biology of the Cell", 1983) to find out what he said, which was:
Most Chromosomal DNA Does Not Code for Essential ProteinsNote "essential" - non-coding DNA is considered "non-essential". And the index, at least, gave no indication as to where any later discussion of other hypotheses could be found. There was little other mention of non-coding DNA throughout the book
...Population biologists have estimated just how much of the DNA of higher organisms actually codes for essential proteins (or is involved in the regulation of genes coding for such proteins). In outline the argument runs as follows: Mutation is an accidental process in which randomly selected nucleotides in the DNA sequence are altered at a low but finite rate. Since most such mutations will be deleterious to the organism when they occur in an essential DNA sequence, there is a limit to the number of essential genes that can be stably maintained. It has been estimated from the observed mutation rate that no more than about 1% of the mammalian genome can be involved in regulating or coding for essential proteins....
What does the rest of the DNA do in higher eucaryotic genomes? We have already suggested that some of it may have a purely structural function in the organization of chromatin. In later sections of this chapter we shall discuss more recent evidence on the nature of the noncoding DNA and some other hypotheses about its function. Whatever the answer(s), the data shown in Figure 8-33 make it clear that it is not a great handicap for a higher cell to carry along a great deal of extra DNA, which suggests that there has been little pressure to minimize DNA content to include only the essential regions.
Even more significant is Goodenough ("Genetics", 3rd Edition, 1984). Again there is no reference to "junk DNA", but there are two short sections that relate to non-coding DNA. Firstly, in the context of considering the chromosome of a virus
...in visualizing the chromosome of T4 we can think of a given single strand of DNA as having long sequences of bases containing meaningful information, followed by long sequences of bases that do not code directly for protein and presumably code for nothing at all.[p.264, emphasis mine]The only other section on "non-coding DNA" referred to in the index is in the section relating to "'Split Genes' in Eukaryotes" -
the coding oregion of most eukaryotic structural genes is interrupted by noncoding sectors, called ... introns.A later section (9.11) talks about the "'Purpose' and Evolution of Intervening Sequences". She writes:
why do eukaryotes "bother" to have introns that they first transcribe and then excise? Several observations are compatible with the theory that introns serve no purpose .... On the other hand, there are indications that at least some introns have functional roles .... Perhaps the most interesting theory is W. Gilbert's proposal that introns might have been important in eukaryotic evolution.... the Gilbert proposal suggests that most present-day introns may be evolutionary relics[her emphasis], once important for creating new eukaryotic genes and persistent simply because cells have no way to get rid of themAs far as I can tell from a quick study, this is all the detail that Goodenough goes into regarding non-coding DNA. There is no obvious reference to the fact that the majority of DNA is "non-coding" and had no known function at the time.
So to conclude, I can't offer evidence on the basis of the information I have to hand that an anti-design hypothesis inhibited research. However, I have demonstrated that this non-coding DNA, despite its significance within a cell, was basically ignored at an undergraduate level as late as the mid-1980's. At best, this suggests that it was considered to have no biological significance; it was "not essential"; non-coding DNA was an "evolutionary relic". What would motivate people to investigate the significance of something when mainstream textbooks had dismissed it in those terms?
Wednesday, June 14, 2006
Another thing about ID ...
In a comment on an earlier post, Corkscrew said:
1) Find an interesting phenomenon
2) Posit that it has no design function
3) Draw concrete, non obvious, testable predictions from this premise
4) Test those predictions
5) Discover that the predictions are accurate
....
Think of some of the interesting phenomena that this has been applied to. Vestigial organs - human coccyx is a vestigial tail, appendix is vestigial from earlier in evolution. Junk DNA - which turns out to have a great deal of significance, and isn't junk at all. Most recently, perhaps, the presence of lactic acid in muscles. The anti-telic approach has proved itself to inhibit science. Perhaps it would be sensible, in the interests of science, if the contrary position were assumed as a starting point ....
In fact, given the challenges that are made to ID, could opponents of ID suggest any occasions when an assumption that something has no design significance has produced any useful science?
If the following process were to be completed, I would consider it strong evidence of design:This is a helpful post. However, what was interesting is that, over the last few decades, it has been shown that the counter-position (if such a concept exists) is pretty useless in scientific terms. How does this run?
1) Find an interesting phenomenon
2) Posit a design hypothesis for it (could include: the Designer's identity, their methodology, their tools etc)
3) Draw concrete, non-obvious*, testable predictions from that premise
4) Test those predictions
5) Discover that the predictions are accurate
6) Repeat a few times with more predictions to ensure it wasn't fluke
7) Submit results to peer-review and fail to have any daft mistakes in methodology pointed out
You don't even really need to show that design happened; you just have to show that it's a scientifically useful concept. If you manage to pull this off, you'll probably get a Nobel, as well as seriously undermining the philosophical argument for atheism.
1) Find an interesting phenomenon
2) Posit that it has no design function
3) Draw concrete, non obvious, testable predictions from this premise
4) Test those predictions
5) Discover that the predictions are accurate
....
Think of some of the interesting phenomena that this has been applied to. Vestigial organs - human coccyx is a vestigial tail, appendix is vestigial from earlier in evolution. Junk DNA - which turns out to have a great deal of significance, and isn't junk at all. Most recently, perhaps, the presence of lactic acid in muscles. The anti-telic approach has proved itself to inhibit science. Perhaps it would be sensible, in the interests of science, if the contrary position were assumed as a starting point ....
In fact, given the challenges that are made to ID, could opponents of ID suggest any occasions when an assumption that something has no design significance has produced any useful science?
Tuesday, June 13, 2006
All quiet on the ID front?
Having established a reputation and a readership on this blog through talking about ID, I have said almost nothing about it for some time. Perhaps any readers still around think I have lost interest. Well, I haven't – though I have come to the conclusion that the debate here wasn't necessarily achieving anything, since the fundamental disagreement was evidently over presuppositions – and if people weren't prepared to accept that their presuppositions had an impact on their interpretation of evidence, then there was little I could hope to achieve in terms of moving the debate on - that is, on to the validity or otherwise of those presuppositions.
However ...
1)I still believe that “design is detectable”, even if it hasn't been rigorously detected yet. Despite the keenness to refute ID as a concept amongst its opponents, I think that the information content in biological systems is significant; I think that irreducible complexity hasn't been shown to be a flawed concept; I think that the link between habitability and observability (Privileged Planet) is significant. I also think that there are other areas which can be explored, though I don't know how yet – I'm not sure that evolutionary processes are sufficient to allow the development of language that can deal with abstraction, for example. Also, one idea that has been teasing around the back of my mind recently – evolution is a story of gradual process, and yet humans are so strongly selected for that with an evolutionary history of 3.5 billion years, they have come to completely dominate the entire planet, and comprehend pretty much the entire universe, in the course of around four thousand years. If this is a consequence of evolution, then frankly its predictive power is negligible. We are told that nothing in biology may make sense except in the light of evolution – but since it seems that evolution couldn't foresee the biological event that has transformed the entire planet in a geological instant, it seems reasonable to argue that evolution has little of use to tell us about humanity.
2)I still believe that much of the opposition to ID is lazy, complacent, arrogant and uninformed. In the sidebar are links to papers that I have critiqued in the past, for various of these reasons. For example, I believe that Lenski et al. have failed to show that irreducible complexity of the level seen in biological systems can evolve, despite the claims of his paper in Nature otherwise. Monton's paper that claimed to discredit Dembski's Universal Probability Bound looks as though it is fundamentally flawed. And the evolution of such features as antibiotic resistance and antifreeze glycoproteins in fish are instances of microevolution rather than macroevolution. Beyond this, the fact that opposition to ID is prepared to resort to judicial processes, and sing the praise of Judge Jones for his clear insight into the issues, rather than successfully refute it on scientific grounds, is very telling. (A judge opposes ID? I mean really, so what?! See also my initial remarks about presuppositions above.) Furthermore, the charges of laziness, complacency, arrogance and lack of informedness are added to by the fact that these flawed attempts to demonstrate the invalidity of ID receive so much promotion and support in the anti-ID community.
3)I believe that this is fundamentally a religious/philosophical debate. Not in the sense that most ID opponents mean this – that is, that ID proponents are only ID proponents because they want to establish a theocracy, or whatever. But that if you reject the idea of external agency, then the whole idea of ID will not be acceptable. If you accept the possibility of external agency, then ID is plausible. The significant things are your religious/philosophical presuppositions. I know that the case of the philosopher Flew is only one, and it probably bears more weight than it deserves, but the significant thing here is at the level of presuppositions - not the conversion to ID, but the shift from atheism to some form of external agencyism.
I still hope to return to the model that I started working on at some stage. In the meantime, I have been interested to find out about another attempt to model evolutionary processes, carried out by Henrik Jeldtoft Jensen and others in the Department of Mathematics at Imperial College, London. Their model is called “Tangled Nature”. It looks at large numbers of digital interacting “species” evolving over hundreds of thousands of generations, and they have used their model to show various things that can be seen in evolutionary history – explosions of new species, for example, and patterns of extinctions. It looks computationally heavy, but interesting nonetheless. Quite a few of these papers are available in arxiv.org – search for “Henrik Jensen” in the maths and quantitative biology sections for more details.
However ...
1)I still believe that “design is detectable”, even if it hasn't been rigorously detected yet. Despite the keenness to refute ID as a concept amongst its opponents, I think that the information content in biological systems is significant; I think that irreducible complexity hasn't been shown to be a flawed concept; I think that the link between habitability and observability (Privileged Planet) is significant. I also think that there are other areas which can be explored, though I don't know how yet – I'm not sure that evolutionary processes are sufficient to allow the development of language that can deal with abstraction, for example. Also, one idea that has been teasing around the back of my mind recently – evolution is a story of gradual process, and yet humans are so strongly selected for that with an evolutionary history of 3.5 billion years, they have come to completely dominate the entire planet, and comprehend pretty much the entire universe, in the course of around four thousand years. If this is a consequence of evolution, then frankly its predictive power is negligible. We are told that nothing in biology may make sense except in the light of evolution – but since it seems that evolution couldn't foresee the biological event that has transformed the entire planet in a geological instant, it seems reasonable to argue that evolution has little of use to tell us about humanity.
2)I still believe that much of the opposition to ID is lazy, complacent, arrogant and uninformed. In the sidebar are links to papers that I have critiqued in the past, for various of these reasons. For example, I believe that Lenski et al. have failed to show that irreducible complexity of the level seen in biological systems can evolve, despite the claims of his paper in Nature otherwise. Monton's paper that claimed to discredit Dembski's Universal Probability Bound looks as though it is fundamentally flawed. And the evolution of such features as antibiotic resistance and antifreeze glycoproteins in fish are instances of microevolution rather than macroevolution. Beyond this, the fact that opposition to ID is prepared to resort to judicial processes, and sing the praise of Judge Jones for his clear insight into the issues, rather than successfully refute it on scientific grounds, is very telling. (A judge opposes ID? I mean really, so what?! See also my initial remarks about presuppositions above.) Furthermore, the charges of laziness, complacency, arrogance and lack of informedness are added to by the fact that these flawed attempts to demonstrate the invalidity of ID receive so much promotion and support in the anti-ID community.
3)I believe that this is fundamentally a religious/philosophical debate. Not in the sense that most ID opponents mean this – that is, that ID proponents are only ID proponents because they want to establish a theocracy, or whatever. But that if you reject the idea of external agency, then the whole idea of ID will not be acceptable. If you accept the possibility of external agency, then ID is plausible. The significant things are your religious/philosophical presuppositions. I know that the case of the philosopher Flew is only one, and it probably bears more weight than it deserves, but the significant thing here is at the level of presuppositions - not the conversion to ID, but the shift from atheism to some form of external agencyism.
I still hope to return to the model that I started working on at some stage. In the meantime, I have been interested to find out about another attempt to model evolutionary processes, carried out by Henrik Jeldtoft Jensen and others in the Department of Mathematics at Imperial College, London. Their model is called “Tangled Nature”. It looks at large numbers of digital interacting “species” evolving over hundreds of thousands of generations, and they have used their model to show various things that can be seen in evolutionary history – explosions of new species, for example, and patterns of extinctions. It looks computationally heavy, but interesting nonetheless. Quite a few of these papers are available in arxiv.org – search for “Henrik Jensen” in the maths and quantitative biology sections for more details.
Thursday, June 08, 2006
Looking forward to the World Cup?
The social side of the England games will be fun - I think I'm around for at least two of the first (haha!) three, and people in the church are getting together for a shared footie experience plus food .... Then there's the shouts and groans audible through open windows when the matches are on. But at the end of the day, it's only a game. Of 90 minutes. With one winner and one loser. I don't suppose I'll be that over the moon if England win, nor as sick as a parrot if they don't win.
My predictions. England will go into the first match against Paraguay on Saturday vastly overconfident, and lose it 0-1, with the goal being late in the second half. They will beat Trinidad and Tobago 2-1, having gone one goal down. They will win their third match against Sweden through a disputed penalty. They will qualify for the next stage on goal difference. Neither Beckham nor Rooney will score, and both will be ineligible to play in the first knockout match, because of yellow cards.
They will then go out in the first knockout stage on penalties, having drawn 0-0.
People talk about favourable draws for the competition, and in theory, England ought to qualify from their group. But to get it in perspective, at the time the draw was made for the competition, somebody pointed out that it should, in actual fact, be irrelevant. If a team isn't able to beat any team on any given day, then they shouldn't be the world cup holders.
Bah, humbug.
My predictions. England will go into the first match against Paraguay on Saturday vastly overconfident, and lose it 0-1, with the goal being late in the second half. They will beat Trinidad and Tobago 2-1, having gone one goal down. They will win their third match against Sweden through a disputed penalty. They will qualify for the next stage on goal difference. Neither Beckham nor Rooney will score, and both will be ineligible to play in the first knockout match, because of yellow cards.
They will then go out in the first knockout stage on penalties, having drawn 0-0.
People talk about favourable draws for the competition, and in theory, England ought to qualify from their group. But to get it in perspective, at the time the draw was made for the competition, somebody pointed out that it should, in actual fact, be irrelevant. If a team isn't able to beat any team on any given day, then they shouldn't be the world cup holders.
Bah, humbug.
Thursday, June 01, 2006
"The Wild"
Madagascar (New York Zoo, animals adapting to a wild environment) meets Finding Nemo (dad looking for son but unable to cope with the wild himself; son coming of age), with a bit of Ice Age 2 (Koala rather than weasel being idolised by Wildebeests rather than ... er, what was it? Dodos?) thrown in for good measure. Mostly harmless. Children will like it. Adults will have seen it all before. That's about it.
It's really uncanny how some of these film studios seem to be mind-locked together. Finding Nemo versus Shark Tale, Madagascar versus The Wild. What gives?
Best line - whilst stalling for time - "Er, what about the ... Party Hats ... of death?"
Most disturbing subplot - a squirrel infatuated with a giraffe. Sufficient grounds on its own to close down every zoo in the world.
It's really uncanny how some of these film studios seem to be mind-locked together. Finding Nemo versus Shark Tale, Madagascar versus The Wild. What gives?
Best line - whilst stalling for time - "Er, what about the ... Party Hats ... of death?"
Most disturbing subplot - a squirrel infatuated with a giraffe. Sufficient grounds on its own to close down every zoo in the world.
Friday, May 26, 2006
When justice is driven back
My brother-in-law and his wife are full-time Christian workers in southern Brazil. They recently posted this about the violence and corruption in the country where they have chosen to work.
The Lord of the Rings Cycle
I finished TLOTR again, and properly read the appendices for the first time. Well, most of them. I really like languages, but I can't get too enthused about the supposed derivation of several fictional ones and their script. Doubtless somebody will tell me how integral they are to the comprehension of Tolkein, but there you go. And I skipped the family trees, as well.
Some more thoughts on the film. I believe that the Peter Jackson trilogy represent a kind of definitive interpretation of the books for cinema. It's unlikely that anybody else will be prepared to spend the millions necessary to do new versions when such definitive versions have been made. One of the real strengths of the films, in my opinion, is the realisation of the characters. With books, a lot of characterisation happens in your imagination, and I know some people rather resent the fact that this interpretation of the books tells them what to think. But what tends to happen is that certain details get mentally filled in by the reader, but all the rest of it is out of focus. The films give some idea of the violence of orcs, for example, which in the books one tends not to dwell on. They illustrate the terrains in the different areas, and Jackson and co have worked hard to make most of the visual details accurate, which is an impressive feat. Particularly things like the Argonath and - is it Amon Sul? - the hill where Boromir tries to take the ring?
That doesn't mean, however, that there ought to be no further visual interpretations. It would be interesting to see whether anybody would be prepared to do a television series, say - each chapter as a one hour episode. That sounds a lot - but then "24" has made it into four or five series, and at one stage, somebody had to commit to making twenty-four episodes with no certainty that the investment would be recovered.
The tone of the episodes would be incredibly varied. Some would be almost all action, and some would be almost all dialogue. This sounds taxing on an audience, but I suspect that the story is compelling enough - and also, sufficiently well known - for such a format to pay its way.
Re-reading the books, it struck me again how much had to be sacrificed even to bring the books down to around 10 hours in length - and also how many subtle ways the plot had been distorted for the sake of the medium. As I've mentioned before, everybody remembers Tom Bombadil. But the whole stretch between Hobbiton and Rivendell is substantially different. In the book, it is Gandalf who pushes to go through Moria, whereas in the film, it is he who is most concerned about what lies there. The exodus from Edoras seems different - there aren't women and children in Helm's Deep in the book. And although the battle gets marginal above ground at Helm's Deep, a large section of the army of Rohan is still intact in the book, which comes out to join in the defeat of Saruman's army when the relieving forces arrive - things don't hang by quite the thread that is implied in the film. And the role of the Palantir in Minas Tirith is disregarded.
On the other hand, there were bits in the film that, on first glance, I didn't think had been in the book, and that Jackson had added just to make the film work better. But the connection between Eowyn and Aragorn was there - it was just that, being pre-adolescent when I read it, I hadn't noticed it. The doubt about whether Rohan will respond to Gondor isn't quite done as Jackson ran it - there is never any doubt in Tolkein's book that Rohan would choose to react to Gondor, because of the two nations' oaths to one another - but Gondor remains unsure that Rohan will react in the book because Gondor's messengers fail to get back from their mission.
I'm not sure about the bits at the end of the book. The scouring of the Shire is an interesting episode - you can see how this fits into the typical hero narrative, and it ties up a whole series of loose ends, but it is somewhat anticlimactic. I don't think that killing off Saruman at Orthanc (as Peter Jackson did, albeit only in the extended version) really did any damage to the narrative.
More another time - though I've already got enough "another time" stuff to fill up several days' worth of posts, so perhaps I'm being unrealistic ....
Some more thoughts on the film. I believe that the Peter Jackson trilogy represent a kind of definitive interpretation of the books for cinema. It's unlikely that anybody else will be prepared to spend the millions necessary to do new versions when such definitive versions have been made. One of the real strengths of the films, in my opinion, is the realisation of the characters. With books, a lot of characterisation happens in your imagination, and I know some people rather resent the fact that this interpretation of the books tells them what to think. But what tends to happen is that certain details get mentally filled in by the reader, but all the rest of it is out of focus. The films give some idea of the violence of orcs, for example, which in the books one tends not to dwell on. They illustrate the terrains in the different areas, and Jackson and co have worked hard to make most of the visual details accurate, which is an impressive feat. Particularly things like the Argonath and - is it Amon Sul? - the hill where Boromir tries to take the ring?
That doesn't mean, however, that there ought to be no further visual interpretations. It would be interesting to see whether anybody would be prepared to do a television series, say - each chapter as a one hour episode. That sounds a lot - but then "24" has made it into four or five series, and at one stage, somebody had to commit to making twenty-four episodes with no certainty that the investment would be recovered.
The tone of the episodes would be incredibly varied. Some would be almost all action, and some would be almost all dialogue. This sounds taxing on an audience, but I suspect that the story is compelling enough - and also, sufficiently well known - for such a format to pay its way.
Re-reading the books, it struck me again how much had to be sacrificed even to bring the books down to around 10 hours in length - and also how many subtle ways the plot had been distorted for the sake of the medium. As I've mentioned before, everybody remembers Tom Bombadil. But the whole stretch between Hobbiton and Rivendell is substantially different. In the book, it is Gandalf who pushes to go through Moria, whereas in the film, it is he who is most concerned about what lies there. The exodus from Edoras seems different - there aren't women and children in Helm's Deep in the book. And although the battle gets marginal above ground at Helm's Deep, a large section of the army of Rohan is still intact in the book, which comes out to join in the defeat of Saruman's army when the relieving forces arrive - things don't hang by quite the thread that is implied in the film. And the role of the Palantir in Minas Tirith is disregarded.
On the other hand, there were bits in the film that, on first glance, I didn't think had been in the book, and that Jackson had added just to make the film work better. But the connection between Eowyn and Aragorn was there - it was just that, being pre-adolescent when I read it, I hadn't noticed it. The doubt about whether Rohan will respond to Gondor isn't quite done as Jackson ran it - there is never any doubt in Tolkein's book that Rohan would choose to react to Gondor, because of the two nations' oaths to one another - but Gondor remains unsure that Rohan will react in the book because Gondor's messengers fail to get back from their mission.
I'm not sure about the bits at the end of the book. The scouring of the Shire is an interesting episode - you can see how this fits into the typical hero narrative, and it ties up a whole series of loose ends, but it is somewhat anticlimactic. I don't think that killing off Saruman at Orthanc (as Peter Jackson did, albeit only in the extended version) really did any damage to the narrative.
More another time - though I've already got enough "another time" stuff to fill up several days' worth of posts, so perhaps I'm being unrealistic ....
Wednesday, May 24, 2006
Windows XP SP2 reboot problem
(... being a selection of words that might get Googled, to help future sufferers ...)
I have spent several days doing battle with one of our computers to try and resolve an issue that arose.
It started with the PC rebooting itself on several occasions. Eventually, it would get as far as the "black screen", but then reboot before it reached the "blue screen" with user names on it.
First thoughts - perhaps a power supply problem (it was only 250 watts) or a motherboard problem. So I bought a new box with 400W PSU and a new motherboard/processor from Maplin, attached the same peripherals ... and the same thing happened.
Okay, so perhaps the installation of Windows was corrupted, by all these reboots before it was running properly. The HDD still worked, so I tucked it into another computer, and copied all the important files onto it, then I tried to reinstall Windows. That was fine to start with, until I installed SP2 - a bit of a battle even getting that far, because doing that much requires reducing the security on the network at home so that the original Windows XP can access the Internet, downloading and installing about 50 incremental updates, and waiting half an hour for SP2 to install. And then ... same symptoms.
Tried it with a new HDD. Same problem. Tried disconnecting everything, to see if it was a hardware fault somewhere else. Same problem.
Eventually, following one more trawl through Google results, I tried it with a different copy of Windows XP - one that had come bundled with a different computer. The usual hours spent updating it - and hey presto! It worked!
So what was going on? I think what had happened was that one of the drivers that was installed with the original installation violated a part of SP2 called Data Execution Prevention, and I had "installed the 32-bit version of Windows XP SP2 on a computer that supports hardware-enforced data execution prevention (DEP)." This may have been the DVD decoder that came with one of the bundled software packages - if so, it wasn't the mpegport.sys one referred to in the Microsoft bulletin. So with the same hardware but a different software package bundled from a different manufacturer, it worked.
How come the problem arose initially? I suspect that this wasn't the actual problem on the original computer, but that there may well have been a PSU problem - and it's just that this other problem became apparent when I tried to run it elsewhere.
Anyway, if you found this by googling because you are having a similar problem, all the best ....
I have spent several days doing battle with one of our computers to try and resolve an issue that arose.
It started with the PC rebooting itself on several occasions. Eventually, it would get as far as the "black screen", but then reboot before it reached the "blue screen" with user names on it.
First thoughts - perhaps a power supply problem (it was only 250 watts) or a motherboard problem. So I bought a new box with 400W PSU and a new motherboard/processor from Maplin, attached the same peripherals ... and the same thing happened.
Okay, so perhaps the installation of Windows was corrupted, by all these reboots before it was running properly. The HDD still worked, so I tucked it into another computer, and copied all the important files onto it, then I tried to reinstall Windows. That was fine to start with, until I installed SP2 - a bit of a battle even getting that far, because doing that much requires reducing the security on the network at home so that the original Windows XP can access the Internet, downloading and installing about 50 incremental updates, and waiting half an hour for SP2 to install. And then ... same symptoms.
Tried it with a new HDD. Same problem. Tried disconnecting everything, to see if it was a hardware fault somewhere else. Same problem.
Eventually, following one more trawl through Google results, I tried it with a different copy of Windows XP - one that had come bundled with a different computer. The usual hours spent updating it - and hey presto! It worked!
So what was going on? I think what had happened was that one of the drivers that was installed with the original installation violated a part of SP2 called Data Execution Prevention, and I had "installed the 32-bit version of Windows XP SP2 on a computer that supports hardware-enforced data execution prevention (DEP)." This may have been the DVD decoder that came with one of the bundled software packages - if so, it wasn't the mpegport.sys one referred to in the Microsoft bulletin. So with the same hardware but a different software package bundled from a different manufacturer, it worked.
How come the problem arose initially? I suspect that this wasn't the actual problem on the original computer, but that there may well have been a PSU problem - and it's just that this other problem became apparent when I tried to run it elsewhere.
Anyway, if you found this by googling because you are having a similar problem, all the best ....
Wednesday, May 17, 2006
Eternal judgement
One of the issues that has arisen in the discussion below is how a being that had created things might chuck them into hell for eternity. Since the conventional wisdom is simply that heaven is "nice" and hell is "horrible", and this idea shapes people's ideas about God, I wanted to add a couple of remarks about this.
Firstly, if there is a God, and somebody has chosen to reject the idea of him being there, then to spend eternity in his presence is hardly preferable to spending eternity away from his presence. There is a line of argument that separation from the God who you have chosen to reject is, in a sense, a final act of mercy.
Secondly, as I was trying to convey in what I wrote in the thread, one of the fundamental "rules" for a god has to be, I think, that the god is consistent with his/her/its own nature - without this, any possibility of meaning and coherence within and beyond the universe goes by the wayside. This means that I suspect that it is far worse for the universe as a whole for God to tolerate things that are wrong than it is for him to be prepared to separate himself from his creatures forever. And, since a price has to be paid for sin, and the Bible concept is that God has done just that for anyone who wishes to be forgiven, you can hardly argue that the Christian God hasn't done what he could to stop free people going to hell, if they choose to seek him.
Thirdly, I think that the exact nature of hell isn't clearly specified. The "burning lake" of Revelation is apocalyptic language, which uses vivid imagery to convey theological truth. Certainly it is a place of regret and separation - which over eternity isn't good. But whether we should understand it to be a place of eternal acute physical torment, I'm not so sure. Personally. Having said that, it's not the case that I have any desire to go there! "The Great Divorce" by C.S.Lewis, in a narrative style, presents a case for, and something of the nature of, the Christian idea of hell - and argues that it is a lot more to do with separation from good things, including relationships. It is worth a read, if the idea of hell bothers you. Incidentally, it is fiction, and although it is helpful, it doesn't override the Bible.
Corkscrew, I'll try and respond more specifically to your comments in that thread when I get the chance .....
Firstly, if there is a God, and somebody has chosen to reject the idea of him being there, then to spend eternity in his presence is hardly preferable to spending eternity away from his presence. There is a line of argument that separation from the God who you have chosen to reject is, in a sense, a final act of mercy.
Secondly, as I was trying to convey in what I wrote in the thread, one of the fundamental "rules" for a god has to be, I think, that the god is consistent with his/her/its own nature - without this, any possibility of meaning and coherence within and beyond the universe goes by the wayside. This means that I suspect that it is far worse for the universe as a whole for God to tolerate things that are wrong than it is for him to be prepared to separate himself from his creatures forever. And, since a price has to be paid for sin, and the Bible concept is that God has done just that for anyone who wishes to be forgiven, you can hardly argue that the Christian God hasn't done what he could to stop free people going to hell, if they choose to seek him.
Thirdly, I think that the exact nature of hell isn't clearly specified. The "burning lake" of Revelation is apocalyptic language, which uses vivid imagery to convey theological truth. Certainly it is a place of regret and separation - which over eternity isn't good. But whether we should understand it to be a place of eternal acute physical torment, I'm not so sure. Personally. Having said that, it's not the case that I have any desire to go there! "The Great Divorce" by C.S.Lewis, in a narrative style, presents a case for, and something of the nature of, the Christian idea of hell - and argues that it is a lot more to do with separation from good things, including relationships. It is worth a read, if the idea of hell bothers you. Incidentally, it is fiction, and although it is helpful, it doesn't override the Bible.
Corkscrew, I'll try and respond more specifically to your comments in that thread when I get the chance .....
Monday, May 15, 2006
Alternate universes
An "Intelligent Design Under Fire" session is to take place at Biola University.
Here's what Scientific American says about it, and this as well. And here's what P.Z.Myers posted on it (what is it about his blog that makes me want to wash my hands having been there?).
Meanwhile, here's what Paul Nelson at ID: The Future said about the same challenge (that ID was rigging its own debate).
To summarize: one side says that ID has hand-picked a bunch of cushy opponents. The other side says that they aren't that cushy, but a whole slew of other people were invited and declined to show up.
"What is truth?"
Here's what Scientific American says about it, and this as well. And here's what P.Z.Myers posted on it (what is it about his blog that makes me want to wash my hands having been there?).
Meanwhile, here's what Paul Nelson at ID: The Future said about the same challenge (that ID was rigging its own debate).
To summarize: one side says that ID has hand-picked a bunch of cushy opponents. The other side says that they aren't that cushy, but a whole slew of other people were invited and declined to show up.
"What is truth?"
Sunday, May 14, 2006
More interesting questions
Exploring ideas raised in a post below, here are some questions from Corkscrew, and quick responses.
OK, so I create an intelligent species of "Corkies" in a universe I've created, and I explain to them that I've created them, I have a right to expect they should acknowledge me as creator. A couple of questions:
1) Why? How does this "right" arise?
I'm not sure that "right" is the right word; I think it's more that this is inherent in the relationship. Probably the closest intuitively analogical relationship in "real life" is between parents and offspring. A denial of that relationship - either from the children to the parents, or the other way round - is incredibly painful, in human terms. And in any case (my wife says, kibbitzing) the relationship exists, whether it is acknowledged or not.
2) What about the 50:50 cases where I only create a proportion of each Corky, and import premade matter to complete the job? To what extent does this taint my intellectual property rights?
Don't know - depends where you got it from, and what bits. Again, thinking about parents and children, children develop their own personalities over the course of time. But that doesn't deny the role of the parent.
3) What else am I allowed to do to the Corkies? Can I:
a) Insist that they obey me in all things
b) Kill them
c) Torture them
d) Encourage them to abuse each other
Hmm, loaded questions, but in the context of this discussion, I'm not sure that they are sufficiently specific. If you create something genuinely free, then you can hardly expect that it will always choose to obey you in all things.* What do you mean by "kill them"? Is it killing a computer program to switch it off when it is running satisfactorily?** What do you mean by "torture them"? Do you mean that you might make something and then treat it in a way that is deliberately against its nature? I think that's about the best way of expressing it in a "creator/creature" relationship. That would strike me as a very odd reason to create something. What do you mean by "abuse each other"? Is that like the things you are talking about doing under the "torturing" heading, but to one another? I think you need more clarity in this question.
4) Are there any circumstances under which I could be considered to have forfeited my rights? For example, if I failed to make it clear to the Corkies that I had created them, would I still be justified in smiting them for not believing?
I think ... if you behaved inconsistently. The White Witch says that if she doesn't have the traitor's blood, then Narnia will be overturned. This sort of thinking - that God/creator is constrained to act in a way that is consistent with himself - seems to underlie a lot of theology. "If God is omnipotent, then can he make something that will destroy him?" Answer: no, because that would not be consistent with his nature. It's a bit like the post-modern problem - the only way that God can exist for one person but not exist for another is (ultimately) if you take away all meaning in language, which is going to make communication impossible. To get postmodernism to work, you have to dismantle the whole universe.
In other words, I think that logic and meaning have to work and apply to the creator, and if not, then the creator forfeits the right to expect a response from his creatures.
I think this applies to God's goodness as well. If God is good, then it would be inconsistent if he were to ignore evil. For God to ignore sin (behaviour that isn't consistent with his own nature) when he oversees the whole universe would be for him to be inconsistent with his own nature, and I think would destroy logic and meaning in the universe.
5) How many of the above questions did you answer by thinking "well, God's done this so it must be OK" rather than actually mulling over the ethical implications? That's the easiest question, but since you know what I would answer, I won't bother. However, it should be pointed out that your choice of language ("smiting", "believing") was hardly religiously unloaded!!
*... and in fact, God didn't. Adam and Eve chose not to obey God, and the rest of humanity followed. God didn't insist that they obeyed him. How can God:
a) allow humans the freedom to do things that are wrong
b) not destroy them and
c) be consistent with his own nature by not ignoring sin?
** Incidentally, if by "killing them" you mean "wiping out all trace of them", you aren't reflecting what the Bible says about humans. It argues that there is an eternal part of us - so if we die - if "God kills us" - the eternal part of us isn't lost.
OK, so I create an intelligent species of "Corkies" in a universe I've created, and I explain to them that I've created them, I have a right to expect they should acknowledge me as creator. A couple of questions:
1) Why? How does this "right" arise?
I'm not sure that "right" is the right word; I think it's more that this is inherent in the relationship. Probably the closest intuitively analogical relationship in "real life" is between parents and offspring. A denial of that relationship - either from the children to the parents, or the other way round - is incredibly painful, in human terms. And in any case (my wife says, kibbitzing) the relationship exists, whether it is acknowledged or not.
2) What about the 50:50 cases where I only create a proportion of each Corky, and import premade matter to complete the job? To what extent does this taint my intellectual property rights?
Don't know - depends where you got it from, and what bits. Again, thinking about parents and children, children develop their own personalities over the course of time. But that doesn't deny the role of the parent.
3) What else am I allowed to do to the Corkies? Can I:
a) Insist that they obey me in all things
b) Kill them
c) Torture them
d) Encourage them to abuse each other
Hmm, loaded questions, but in the context of this discussion, I'm not sure that they are sufficiently specific. If you create something genuinely free, then you can hardly expect that it will always choose to obey you in all things.* What do you mean by "kill them"? Is it killing a computer program to switch it off when it is running satisfactorily?** What do you mean by "torture them"? Do you mean that you might make something and then treat it in a way that is deliberately against its nature? I think that's about the best way of expressing it in a "creator/creature" relationship. That would strike me as a very odd reason to create something. What do you mean by "abuse each other"? Is that like the things you are talking about doing under the "torturing" heading, but to one another? I think you need more clarity in this question.
4) Are there any circumstances under which I could be considered to have forfeited my rights? For example, if I failed to make it clear to the Corkies that I had created them, would I still be justified in smiting them for not believing?
I think ... if you behaved inconsistently. The White Witch says that if she doesn't have the traitor's blood, then Narnia will be overturned. This sort of thinking - that God/creator is constrained to act in a way that is consistent with himself - seems to underlie a lot of theology. "If God is omnipotent, then can he make something that will destroy him?" Answer: no, because that would not be consistent with his nature. It's a bit like the post-modern problem - the only way that God can exist for one person but not exist for another is (ultimately) if you take away all meaning in language, which is going to make communication impossible. To get postmodernism to work, you have to dismantle the whole universe.
In other words, I think that logic and meaning have to work and apply to the creator, and if not, then the creator forfeits the right to expect a response from his creatures.
I think this applies to God's goodness as well. If God is good, then it would be inconsistent if he were to ignore evil. For God to ignore sin (behaviour that isn't consistent with his own nature) when he oversees the whole universe would be for him to be inconsistent with his own nature, and I think would destroy logic and meaning in the universe.
5) How many of the above questions did you answer by thinking "well, God's done this so it must be OK" rather than actually mulling over the ethical implications? That's the easiest question, but since you know what I would answer, I won't bother. However, it should be pointed out that your choice of language ("smiting", "believing") was hardly religiously unloaded!!
*... and in fact, God didn't. Adam and Eve chose not to obey God, and the rest of humanity followed. God didn't insist that they obeyed him. How can God:
a) allow humans the freedom to do things that are wrong
b) not destroy them and
c) be consistent with his own nature by not ignoring sin?
** Incidentally, if by "killing them" you mean "wiping out all trace of them", you aren't reflecting what the Bible says about humans. It argues that there is an eternal part of us - so if we die - if "God kills us" - the eternal part of us isn't lost.
Saturday, May 13, 2006
Irreducible complexity in Scientific American
An article has been written in Scientific American which talks about irreducible complexity.
Okay, so it's not particularly the ID variety. It's in the March 2006 issue, and it's on "The Limits of Reason". The author, Gregory Chaitin, points out that Godel's Incompleteness Theorem "did for" the idea of maths as a unifying principle for knowledge, by demonstrating that there are statements in maths that can't be proved. He explores the idea that there are also numbers that are well defined, but can't be written down.
"Hang on," I hear you say, "aren't the square root of two and pi and other irrational numbers like that?" No - the point he is getting at is that you can write a short algorithm that will derive each of these. But you can't write a short algorithm that will derive other classes of numbers. So not only are they irrational, they also contain a lot of algorithmic information.
In actual fact, this article does have some relevance to ID. For example, in debates a few months ago here, we talked about whether random processes could generate meaningful amounts of information. Chaitin points out that "a useful theory is a compression of the data; comprehension is compression. You compress things into computer programs, into concise algorithmic descriptions. The simpler the theory, the better you understand something."
So take a random sequence of letters. The specification "means something in English" is fairly concise - even though the implementation of this in algorithmic terms is complex. However, to argue that "we can't exclude the possibility that this contains information in a conceivable code" doesn't mean that the letters contain more information - or may contain more information - because if the algorithmic complexity is high (the amount of programming required to demonstrate the information content), then the stream of letters is incompressible; they have no redundancy; "the best one can do is transmit them directly. They are called irreducible or algorithmically random."
I think that this article then effectively endorses some aspects of Dembski's arguments about the nature of complexity, and certainly seems to weaken some of the counter-analyses.
Okay, so it's not particularly the ID variety. It's in the March 2006 issue, and it's on "The Limits of Reason". The author, Gregory Chaitin, points out that Godel's Incompleteness Theorem "did for" the idea of maths as a unifying principle for knowledge, by demonstrating that there are statements in maths that can't be proved. He explores the idea that there are also numbers that are well defined, but can't be written down.
"Hang on," I hear you say, "aren't the square root of two and pi and other irrational numbers like that?" No - the point he is getting at is that you can write a short algorithm that will derive each of these. But you can't write a short algorithm that will derive other classes of numbers. So not only are they irrational, they also contain a lot of algorithmic information.
In actual fact, this article does have some relevance to ID. For example, in debates a few months ago here, we talked about whether random processes could generate meaningful amounts of information. Chaitin points out that "a useful theory is a compression of the data; comprehension is compression. You compress things into computer programs, into concise algorithmic descriptions. The simpler the theory, the better you understand something."
So take a random sequence of letters. The specification "means something in English" is fairly concise - even though the implementation of this in algorithmic terms is complex. However, to argue that "we can't exclude the possibility that this contains information in a conceivable code" doesn't mean that the letters contain more information - or may contain more information - because if the algorithmic complexity is high (the amount of programming required to demonstrate the information content), then the stream of letters is incompressible; they have no redundancy; "the best one can do is transmit them directly. They are called irreducible or algorithmically random."
I think that this article then effectively endorses some aspects of Dembski's arguments about the nature of complexity, and certainly seems to weaken some of the counter-analyses.
Tuesday, May 09, 2006
Freedom as creatures
A commenter has said that anything that, from a Christian perspective, all we experience is ultimately only "borrowed" from God - from this perspective, our emotions have no more substance than those of dolls at a children's tea party. A non-theistic perspective at least allows us to have our own emotions.
I think this underplays the Christian perspective, and it also overplays the non-Christian one. From a non-theistic perspective, our emotions, whilst they may not be derivative, have no significance. The fact that (for example) my wife matters so much to me, or that I care so much about people dying of AIDS in the developing world, amounts to a cosmic zero, because my consciousness is simply a by-product of my genes' struggle for survival - no, even that implies too much significance - the fact that over the course of time, some sequences of DNA are chemically more likely to reproduce than others. And ultimately the whole universe is a zero - a quantum fluctuation that happens to be here, but might just as easily not have been.
But people don't operate on that basis. They care for themselves - they make sure that they are sheltered, fed and even pampered, as far as they are able to. They make moral decisions - not believing that they are actually cosmic zeroes, but as though it actually matters. As before, I know that you can talk in terms of the evolutionary advantages of altruism and love, and so on, but the problem is that every term needs to be replaced with zeroes. Altruism is zero. Love is zero. Evolution is zero. Everything is zero - because if not long before, at the time of the heat death of the universe, there will be nothing left. No matter what other factors you use, zero is one of them - so the product is always zero. I am not satisfied with the atheistic worldview because I don't believe that people genuinely operate as though it is true.
What about from a Christian perspective, then? Can we get past the idea of derivative emotions - that they have no significance because they are only what God has put there?
In the past, I have used the analogy of a computer program and a programmer to think about the relationship between us as created and a god as creator. Supposing a program is written to evaluate some data, in some circumstances, and make an assessment of the characteristics of the writer that have been specified. Supposing that it says: "J. Smith, who wrote this program, is cool." From the program's point of view, this reflects a genuine interpretation of data, a conclusion that it freely came to. From the perspective of the programmer, he may be able to say: "Well, the program was always going to come to that conclusion."
As a Christian, I believe that God has "programmed" us, and that he does know how we are going to respond, and what the outcome of all our decisions is - I have a strong view of the sovereignty of God. But whilst I have that view, I don't know what God's purposes are. I don't know what God intends to happen. And as far as I am concerned, the decisions I make are freely made. Our response may be deterministic, as far as God is concerned, but God's hand is so imperceptible that from my perspective it is indistinguishable from me being free. I am far freer in what I express than any computer program, let alone any doll at a child's tea party.
You only have to look at the Bible to see that this is a fair reflection of the nature of things. Would Adam and Eve really have eaten from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil if they had known what would happen? Would Judas really have betrayed Jesus if he had known what would happen next? Would you have? And yet, Jesus had pretty much told him that he was going to be betrayed. The contrast between "the purposes of evil men" and "the foreknowledge of God" is brought out strongly in Peter's sermons in Acts.
I think this is why the narrative idea of nemesis/destiny/fate is so strong, in all sorts of cultures (Shakespeare, Tolkein, Homer, ... er, Rowling). People know that this is how the world is - that regardless of the freedom that they perceive, there are "forces at work" which bring about particular ends. From a Christian perspective, those forces are embodied in the sovereignty of God.
The idea of the Christian God, and human nature is stronger than that. We are created - but we are created to respond as we choose. Imagine a better computer program, now - one that can evaluate data about everybody in the world, and come to a conclusion about who its "favourite" person is. Supposing this program still concluded that the writer was a cool person: wouldn't the programmer be more satisfied with its response, even though (in principle) it is possible to establish that it was always going to say that? How good would a computer program have to be before the programmer would "take delight" in its responses?
A program has an "About..." box, which includes copyright and licence details. Supposing somebody hacks into the program, and replaces the contents of the About box with his own details. Would not the original programmer be rightfully angry with the hacker?
I think this underplays the Christian perspective, and it also overplays the non-Christian one. From a non-theistic perspective, our emotions, whilst they may not be derivative, have no significance. The fact that (for example) my wife matters so much to me, or that I care so much about people dying of AIDS in the developing world, amounts to a cosmic zero, because my consciousness is simply a by-product of my genes' struggle for survival - no, even that implies too much significance - the fact that over the course of time, some sequences of DNA are chemically more likely to reproduce than others. And ultimately the whole universe is a zero - a quantum fluctuation that happens to be here, but might just as easily not have been.
But people don't operate on that basis. They care for themselves - they make sure that they are sheltered, fed and even pampered, as far as they are able to. They make moral decisions - not believing that they are actually cosmic zeroes, but as though it actually matters. As before, I know that you can talk in terms of the evolutionary advantages of altruism and love, and so on, but the problem is that every term needs to be replaced with zeroes. Altruism is zero. Love is zero. Evolution is zero. Everything is zero - because if not long before, at the time of the heat death of the universe, there will be nothing left. No matter what other factors you use, zero is one of them - so the product is always zero. I am not satisfied with the atheistic worldview because I don't believe that people genuinely operate as though it is true.
What about from a Christian perspective, then? Can we get past the idea of derivative emotions - that they have no significance because they are only what God has put there?
In the past, I have used the analogy of a computer program and a programmer to think about the relationship between us as created and a god as creator. Supposing a program is written to evaluate some data, in some circumstances, and make an assessment of the characteristics of the writer that have been specified. Supposing that it says: "J. Smith, who wrote this program, is cool." From the program's point of view, this reflects a genuine interpretation of data, a conclusion that it freely came to. From the perspective of the programmer, he may be able to say: "Well, the program was always going to come to that conclusion."
As a Christian, I believe that God has "programmed" us, and that he does know how we are going to respond, and what the outcome of all our decisions is - I have a strong view of the sovereignty of God. But whilst I have that view, I don't know what God's purposes are. I don't know what God intends to happen. And as far as I am concerned, the decisions I make are freely made. Our response may be deterministic, as far as God is concerned, but God's hand is so imperceptible that from my perspective it is indistinguishable from me being free. I am far freer in what I express than any computer program, let alone any doll at a child's tea party.
You only have to look at the Bible to see that this is a fair reflection of the nature of things. Would Adam and Eve really have eaten from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil if they had known what would happen? Would Judas really have betrayed Jesus if he had known what would happen next? Would you have? And yet, Jesus had pretty much told him that he was going to be betrayed. The contrast between "the purposes of evil men" and "the foreknowledge of God" is brought out strongly in Peter's sermons in Acts.
I think this is why the narrative idea of nemesis/destiny/fate is so strong, in all sorts of cultures (Shakespeare, Tolkein, Homer, ... er, Rowling). People know that this is how the world is - that regardless of the freedom that they perceive, there are "forces at work" which bring about particular ends. From a Christian perspective, those forces are embodied in the sovereignty of God.
The idea of the Christian God, and human nature is stronger than that. We are created - but we are created to respond as we choose. Imagine a better computer program, now - one that can evaluate data about everybody in the world, and come to a conclusion about who its "favourite" person is. Supposing this program still concluded that the writer was a cool person: wouldn't the programmer be more satisfied with its response, even though (in principle) it is possible to establish that it was always going to say that? How good would a computer program have to be before the programmer would "take delight" in its responses?
A program has an "About..." box, which includes copyright and licence details. Supposing somebody hacks into the program, and replaces the contents of the About box with his own details. Would not the original programmer be rightfully angry with the hacker?
Monday, May 08, 2006
Coyne: bovvad?
This follows on from an earlier post. If you want to know what this discussion is about, see the comments following this post. I'm afraid that this is a bit train-of-thoughty and unstructured.
George Coyne, the Vatican astronomer, has dismissed Intelligent Design as (in effect) anti-Christian. Now Coyne was working from his own presuppositions - namely, that God (pretty much) doesn't intervene in the universe. Only he didn't even realise that these presuppositions were there. Few people do. One of my missions in life is to make people aware of their presuppositions.
The thing is, those people who deny the possibility of God working in the universe (if that's what it comes down to - that is, God involved in creation, miracles, resurrection) have moved so far from the Christian faith that they can no longer realistically be called Christians. It doesn't matter whether he is the Vatican astronomer or not - in fact, his job is a distraction. It doesn't matter whether the Pope, the Archbishop of Canterbury (or Bishop of Durham, a few years ago), Ian Paisley, me or the minister of my church denies that God is able to work in the universe. Whoever says that is denying the Christian faith, which says that God created the universe, and "he does whatever he pleases". This isn't "anti-science" - because God has made the universe by and large tractable to our human minds.
Incidentally, if you don't believe in God, the tractability of the universe causes you problems - it was no less a person than Einstein who said, "The most incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it's comprehensible." It's not only that we can understand and take our place in our environment, like animals do - but we can understand in scientific terms the Big Bang, quasars and quarks. You can doubtless make up some evolutionary story as to why there is a selective advantage in us being able to do this - because you can make up evolutionary stories to explain everything. But since this level of comprehension of the universe has at the very least not been extended to any other creature by evolution, I am pretty sceptical about the strength of post-hoc evolutionary explanations.
Furthermore, we are in the ironic situation where there are some scientists who are saying "despite the appearance of design, things aren't designed by intelligent processes" - which some theologians are then presenting as, "despite the appearance of non-design, we see the involvement of God through faith [i.e. as an irrational postmodern leap of faith]". In other words, theologians are arguing that our appreciation of God in the universe is fundamentally an irrational act.
Now, I don't think that belief in God is irrational and unreasonable. In fact, I think that the natures of the universe and personality are strongly indicative of an infinite-personal deity, and that supposedly Christian people who deny that have been cowed into submission by the naturalistic worldview of academia around them. Furthermore, this seems to me to be consistent with what the Bible teaches - not just by picking out a verse or two as a proof text, but looking at the structure of the argument in Romans 1 (that evidence of God is obvious, but people suppress what they know, and as judgement, God closes their mind even further): 1 Corinthians - the first bit - where Paul talks about the fact that the Greeks look for knowledge (rationalism) and the Jews look for wonders (an "experience" of God) but Christianity is foolishness to the Greeks and a stumbling block to the Jews: and Acts 17, for example, where Paul addresses the Greeks and points out to them that if there is really a god, then he is hardly likely to be impressed by people making statues of him.
Also, because of what God is like, there is an artificial dichotomy between "supernatural" and "natural". As far as the Bible is concerned, God's power is as much involved in the maintenance of the universe (causing the sun to rise, making sure that wild animals have food etc) as he is in the miraculous. What naturalism seeks to do is to say that the maintenance of the universe is automatic (and doesn't require God) and the supernatural never happened. This isn't consistent with the Bible, and really, as far as I can tell, has no sound empirical foundation. It works, as long as you are able to deny the supernatural, but there is no reason for it to work, and intellectually it is no more nor less arbitrary than belief in God. Oh, I suppose that you can invoke Occam's Razor to deny the fact that God is there. But if you're going to do that, why not keep on shaving until you get rid of us as well?
George Coyne, the Vatican astronomer, has dismissed Intelligent Design as (in effect) anti-Christian. Now Coyne was working from his own presuppositions - namely, that God (pretty much) doesn't intervene in the universe. Only he didn't even realise that these presuppositions were there. Few people do. One of my missions in life is to make people aware of their presuppositions.
The thing is, those people who deny the possibility of God working in the universe (if that's what it comes down to - that is, God involved in creation, miracles, resurrection) have moved so far from the Christian faith that they can no longer realistically be called Christians. It doesn't matter whether he is the Vatican astronomer or not - in fact, his job is a distraction. It doesn't matter whether the Pope, the Archbishop of Canterbury (or Bishop of Durham, a few years ago), Ian Paisley, me or the minister of my church denies that God is able to work in the universe. Whoever says that is denying the Christian faith, which says that God created the universe, and "he does whatever he pleases". This isn't "anti-science" - because God has made the universe by and large tractable to our human minds.
Incidentally, if you don't believe in God, the tractability of the universe causes you problems - it was no less a person than Einstein who said, "The most incomprehensible thing about the universe is that it's comprehensible." It's not only that we can understand and take our place in our environment, like animals do - but we can understand in scientific terms the Big Bang, quasars and quarks. You can doubtless make up some evolutionary story as to why there is a selective advantage in us being able to do this - because you can make up evolutionary stories to explain everything. But since this level of comprehension of the universe has at the very least not been extended to any other creature by evolution, I am pretty sceptical about the strength of post-hoc evolutionary explanations.
Furthermore, we are in the ironic situation where there are some scientists who are saying "despite the appearance of design, things aren't designed by intelligent processes" - which some theologians are then presenting as, "despite the appearance of non-design, we see the involvement of God through faith [i.e. as an irrational postmodern leap of faith]". In other words, theologians are arguing that our appreciation of God in the universe is fundamentally an irrational act.
Now, I don't think that belief in God is irrational and unreasonable. In fact, I think that the natures of the universe and personality are strongly indicative of an infinite-personal deity, and that supposedly Christian people who deny that have been cowed into submission by the naturalistic worldview of academia around them. Furthermore, this seems to me to be consistent with what the Bible teaches - not just by picking out a verse or two as a proof text, but looking at the structure of the argument in Romans 1 (that evidence of God is obvious, but people suppress what they know, and as judgement, God closes their mind even further): 1 Corinthians - the first bit - where Paul talks about the fact that the Greeks look for knowledge (rationalism) and the Jews look for wonders (an "experience" of God) but Christianity is foolishness to the Greeks and a stumbling block to the Jews: and Acts 17, for example, where Paul addresses the Greeks and points out to them that if there is really a god, then he is hardly likely to be impressed by people making statues of him.
Also, because of what God is like, there is an artificial dichotomy between "supernatural" and "natural". As far as the Bible is concerned, God's power is as much involved in the maintenance of the universe (causing the sun to rise, making sure that wild animals have food etc) as he is in the miraculous. What naturalism seeks to do is to say that the maintenance of the universe is automatic (and doesn't require God) and the supernatural never happened. This isn't consistent with the Bible, and really, as far as I can tell, has no sound empirical foundation. It works, as long as you are able to deny the supernatural, but there is no reason for it to work, and intellectually it is no more nor less arbitrary than belief in God. Oh, I suppose that you can invoke Occam's Razor to deny the fact that God is there. But if you're going to do that, why not keep on shaving until you get rid of us as well?
Saturday, May 06, 2006
Bono vs Dogbert
It's always a bit disconcerting when two people you have so much respect for meet each other - how will they get on?
Intimacy
If I hear two good songs from an album, then the chances are I'll buy it. If I like an album from an artist, then there's a good chance that I'll also buy the next one or the previous one. That's how come I downloaded Tess Wiley's "Not Quite Me" and then "Rainy Day Assembly" - about which more another time.
I can't remember what led me to buy the Corrs' "Talk on Corners". It wasn't the smug, tedious "So Young", nor was it the unedifying "Runaway" - so I guess, in terms of singles, "What can I do" probably had most to do with it.
There are, however, two excellent tracks on it. "Queen of Hollywood" is good, but the band just doesn't quite have the passion that the singer and the words demand. But "Intimacy" is one of the most amazing songs not only sung by the Corrs, but by anyone.
The writing credits aren't theirs, unlike many of the songs on their albums (though they also borrowed Hendrix's "Little Wing", and somewhat gaelified it). The writers credited are Rick Nowels and Neil Geraldo. The first verse has words of uncertainty in the night:
I can't remember what led me to buy the Corrs' "Talk on Corners". It wasn't the smug, tedious "So Young", nor was it the unedifying "Runaway" - so I guess, in terms of singles, "What can I do" probably had most to do with it.
There are, however, two excellent tracks on it. "Queen of Hollywood" is good, but the band just doesn't quite have the passion that the singer and the words demand. But "Intimacy" is one of the most amazing songs not only sung by the Corrs, but by anyone.
The writing credits aren't theirs, unlike many of the songs on their albums (though they also borrowed Hendrix's "Little Wing", and somewhat gaelified it). The writers credited are Rick Nowels and Neil Geraldo. The first verse has words of uncertainty in the night:
Last night before you fell asleep... and the rest of the song looks at the loneliness of the world, and the need for somebody to share that loneliness with.
You whispered something to me
Was it just a dream?
I’m gonna listen to you close
Cause your goodnight kiss
Felt like a ghost
What are you trying to say to me?
What are you trying to say?
Everybody’s searching for intimacy
Everybody’s hurting for intimacy
Companionship, and especially marriage, are gifts from God, and integral to who we are as human beings, so that this lonely, fragmented world need not be. The uncertainty, nervousness and suspicion that is the undercurrent of this song is the experience of too many people. The song is powerful because it lays bare the emotions that so many people suppress for so much of the time.
We come into this world alone
From the heart of darkness
The infinite unknown
We’re only here a little while
And I feel safe and warm
When I see your smile
Baby don’t move away from me
Baby don’t pull away
Remember when you were a child
And your momma would hold you in her arms
And rock you to sleep
Now darling there’s just you and I
Let’s give each other everything, baby baby...
Everybody’s searching for intimacy
Everybody’s hurting for intimacy
Baby come and lay down next to me...
Everybody’s searching for intimacy
Tuesday, May 02, 2006
If ID is religion, then opposition is discrimination
At Telic Thoughts, Joy pointed out the following.
1) The Dover vs Kitzmiller trial demonstrated, to the satisfaction of many opponents of Intelligent Design, that ID is religious, not scientific.
2) There are people (such as P.Z.Myers) who are prepared to veto tenure appointments simply on the grounds that somebody believes in ID - they don't even need to teach it.
3) Given 1 above, this represents religious discrimination, which is not constitutionally permissible.
I can't see a logical fault in this argument - that if somebody holds that Judge Jones' verdict is sound, then discrimination of the sort talked about by P.Z.Myers is not permissible. Unfortunately, the discussion in the comments section ended up sidetracked by discussion about Jehovah's Witnesses and blood donation, vegetarianism and interpretation of the Bible. But this meant that the real discussion ceased about a third of the way into the comments.
Now, I don't think that the verdict was sound, and I am not pleading "religious discrimination." But what I want to know is how those people who think the verdict is sound can believe that P.Z.Myers' attitude can be acceptable, on constitutional grounds.
1) The Dover vs Kitzmiller trial demonstrated, to the satisfaction of many opponents of Intelligent Design, that ID is religious, not scientific.
2) There are people (such as P.Z.Myers) who are prepared to veto tenure appointments simply on the grounds that somebody believes in ID - they don't even need to teach it.
3) Given 1 above, this represents religious discrimination, which is not constitutionally permissible.
I can't see a logical fault in this argument - that if somebody holds that Judge Jones' verdict is sound, then discrimination of the sort talked about by P.Z.Myers is not permissible. Unfortunately, the discussion in the comments section ended up sidetracked by discussion about Jehovah's Witnesses and blood donation, vegetarianism and interpretation of the Bible. But this meant that the real discussion ceased about a third of the way into the comments.
Now, I don't think that the verdict was sound, and I am not pleading "religious discrimination." But what I want to know is how those people who think the verdict is sound can believe that P.Z.Myers' attitude can be acceptable, on constitutional grounds.
Monday, May 01, 2006
"Songs of Praise" Top 10
"Songs of Praise" is the BBC flagship religious programme, and it has been running since 1961. On Sunday, the programme counted down the nation's favourite hymns/songs, as voted for by viewers of SoP. I thought I'd chip in my two penn'orth, since they didn't bother to interview me.
10. Shine Jesus Shine (Graham Kendrick)
Kendrick has written much better. But this is the one that everybody knows, and probably one of the few modern Christian songs that has become widely known amongst non-Christians, by virtue of weddings and school assemblies. Would not have been in my top 10.
9. In Christ alone (Stuart Townend)
This would certainly have been in my top 10 - probably pretty high. An outstanding modern hymn.
8. Guide me O Thou Great Redeemer
... with the Welsh tune "Cwm Rhondda", no doubt. Would probably be in my top 10 - there would have to be several good Welsh tunes there. The words do it no harm, either.
7. Make me a channel of your peace
Not in my top 10. Another favourite for weddings and schools. I'll probably get shot for this, but I think St. Francis is a bit drippy, really. But then, I'm not really into all this escaping from the world by taking holy orders, and I don't think he really took the Bible very seriously.
6. Be still for the presence of the Lord
Sigh. If you're going to pick modern songs, make them good ones, not just OK ones. This would not have been in my top 10.
5. Love divine
Definitely pick the Welsh tune (Blaenwern) over the original one. I wonder if people chose it for the words or just for the tune?
4. Be thou my vision
A bit of Celtish influence, and a reminder that profound Christian expression doesn't only come after the Reformation.
3. The day thou gavest
Very stirring song, but again, wouldn't be in my top 10.
2. Dear Lord and Father of mankind
The programme noted the fact that this poem was written because the writer didn't approve of hymn singing. Ironic. Quite a nice hymn, but I always had problems choosing it because of the blatant disregard of the author's intention.
1. How Great thou art
Hmm. I guess that this might appear on a list of my 100 favourite, but I don't think it would make the top 10.
So what ought to have been there? I'm surprised that "Amazing grace" wasn't there. Or "When I survey the Wondrous Cross". Or "My song is love unknown." What about "And can it be?" In my own list, I would have chosen "There is a day", "I'll praise my maker while I've breath" and "All I once held dear". Possibly "When the Lord in glory comes". Possibly "Immortal honours rest on Jesus' head". So there you go.
On the SoP website, they also have an interview with Rev. James Jones, Bishop of Liverpool, on God's grace, which even makes reference to the U2 song of the same name.
10. Shine Jesus Shine (Graham Kendrick)
Kendrick has written much better. But this is the one that everybody knows, and probably one of the few modern Christian songs that has become widely known amongst non-Christians, by virtue of weddings and school assemblies. Would not have been in my top 10.
9. In Christ alone (Stuart Townend)
This would certainly have been in my top 10 - probably pretty high. An outstanding modern hymn.
8. Guide me O Thou Great Redeemer
... with the Welsh tune "Cwm Rhondda", no doubt. Would probably be in my top 10 - there would have to be several good Welsh tunes there. The words do it no harm, either.
7. Make me a channel of your peace
Not in my top 10. Another favourite for weddings and schools. I'll probably get shot for this, but I think St. Francis is a bit drippy, really. But then, I'm not really into all this escaping from the world by taking holy orders, and I don't think he really took the Bible very seriously.
6. Be still for the presence of the Lord
Sigh. If you're going to pick modern songs, make them good ones, not just OK ones. This would not have been in my top 10.
5. Love divine
Definitely pick the Welsh tune (Blaenwern) over the original one. I wonder if people chose it for the words or just for the tune?
4. Be thou my vision
A bit of Celtish influence, and a reminder that profound Christian expression doesn't only come after the Reformation.
3. The day thou gavest
Very stirring song, but again, wouldn't be in my top 10.
2. Dear Lord and Father of mankind
The programme noted the fact that this poem was written because the writer didn't approve of hymn singing. Ironic. Quite a nice hymn, but I always had problems choosing it because of the blatant disregard of the author's intention.
1. How Great thou art
Hmm. I guess that this might appear on a list of my 100 favourite, but I don't think it would make the top 10.
So what ought to have been there? I'm surprised that "Amazing grace" wasn't there. Or "When I survey the Wondrous Cross". Or "My song is love unknown." What about "And can it be?" In my own list, I would have chosen "There is a day", "I'll praise my maker while I've breath" and "All I once held dear". Possibly "When the Lord in glory comes". Possibly "Immortal honours rest on Jesus' head". So there you go.
On the SoP website, they also have an interview with Rev. James Jones, Bishop of Liverpool, on God's grace, which even makes reference to the U2 song of the same name.
Monday, April 24, 2006
The problem of evil
John Blanchard, in his apologetic book, "Does God believe in Atheists?" argues that the problem of evil is the key intellectual problem that faces Christians in defending their beliefs. In short, the heart of the problem lies in the tension that exists between three propositions:
1) God is good
2) God is omnipotent
3) Evil exists
John Blanchard provides a Christian response to this problem in his book. Readers may be interested to know that William Dembski, more famous for his involvement in the Intelligent Design movement, has also turned his philosophical/theological brain to this issue. Here is a link to his paper "Christian Theodicy in Light of Genesis and Modern Science" - it is a 130KB PDF file.
1) God is good
2) God is omnipotent
3) Evil exists
John Blanchard provides a Christian response to this problem in his book. Readers may be interested to know that William Dembski, more famous for his involvement in the Intelligent Design movement, has also turned his philosophical/theological brain to this issue. Here is a link to his paper "Christian Theodicy in Light of Genesis and Modern Science" - it is a 130KB PDF file.
The Earth as a place for soul-making also leaves much to be desired. The metaphor here is that of a school that attempts to train us to become great souls. But rigors of a curriculum are one thing; Lisbon earthquakes
and Asian tsunamis, not to mention Auschwitz and the Killing Fields, are another. Do we really need a curriculum that grinds so many of its students to powder? If the Earth is indeed a place for soul-making, how many great souls does it in fact produce? Is it not a tiny, tiny minority? How many flunk out Hick’s school of soul-making? How many do not merely flunk out but end up in the gutter, addicted to sensuality, money, fame, or power? How many cannot be said to have enrolled in any school whatsoever, whose days are consumed in struggling to survive (think of
bare-footed children scouring garbage dumps to eke out an existence)?
Solar power - infeasibility study
The two key resources for the next century, in my opinion, will be information and power. There's not much I can do about information - there is a limit to the rate at which I can produce it or organise it, and Google are doing a much better job! But I would love to be more independent in terms of power.
We are in a valley, sheltered by trees, so wind energy isn't likely to do much for us here - I think the neighbours might not be keen on a 20 metre high windmill. So, since we are having building work done, I spent some time looking at options for solar energy. This falls into two basic categories: solar PV (photovoltaic) (producing electricity using photoelectric plates) and solar water heating. Both have come a long way in the last 20 years or so - but both are still very expensive. Prices seem to be set so that the cost of installation will only be recovered over the expected life of the equipment. To buy a solar PV system which produces up to a kilowatt peak output costs several thousand pounds - and will produce savings of £100 to £300 per year. Water heating systems are cheaper - you can get one from about £1600 - but not as useful anyway, since they only provide hot water - they can't be used to heat the house, so you still need a boiler for central heating.
Basically, the price is such that microgeneration of solar energy is still an ideological luxury for most people. SolarCentury have a vision for every roof in the country being a mini power station. This would generate enough electricity to supply the whole country. It would also provide revenue for the solar PV manufacturers of tens of billions of pounds. The bottom line is: if solar PV were so good, solar PV manufacturers wouldn't bother with selling systems. They'd be buying land to put their systems on and just selling the power.
We are in a valley, sheltered by trees, so wind energy isn't likely to do much for us here - I think the neighbours might not be keen on a 20 metre high windmill. So, since we are having building work done, I spent some time looking at options for solar energy. This falls into two basic categories: solar PV (photovoltaic) (producing electricity using photoelectric plates) and solar water heating. Both have come a long way in the last 20 years or so - but both are still very expensive. Prices seem to be set so that the cost of installation will only be recovered over the expected life of the equipment. To buy a solar PV system which produces up to a kilowatt peak output costs several thousand pounds - and will produce savings of £100 to £300 per year. Water heating systems are cheaper - you can get one from about £1600 - but not as useful anyway, since they only provide hot water - they can't be used to heat the house, so you still need a boiler for central heating.
Basically, the price is such that microgeneration of solar energy is still an ideological luxury for most people. SolarCentury have a vision for every roof in the country being a mini power station. This would generate enough electricity to supply the whole country. It would also provide revenue for the solar PV manufacturers of tens of billions of pounds. The bottom line is: if solar PV were so good, solar PV manufacturers wouldn't bother with selling systems. They'd be buying land to put their systems on and just selling the power.
Thursday, April 20, 2006
Tolkein: Can pantheism save the world?
"Could we not still send messages to [Tom Bombadil] and obtain his help?" asked Erestor. "It seems that he has a power even over the Ring."
"No, I should not put it so," said Gandalf. "Say rather that the Ring has no power over him. He is his own master. But he cannot alter the Ring itself, nor break its power over others. And now he is withdrawn into a little land, within bounds that he has set, though none can see them, waiting perhaps for a change of days, and he will not step beyond them."
"But within those bounds nothing seems to dismay him," said Erestor. "Would he not take the Ring and keep it there, for ever harmless?"
"No," said Gandalf, "not willingly. He might do so, if all the free folk of the world begged him, but he would not understand the need. And if he were given the Ring, he would soon forget it, or most likely throw it away. Such things have no hold on his mind. He would be a most unsafe guardian; and that alone is answer enough."
"But in any case," said Glorfindel, "to send the Ring to him would only postpone the day of evil. He is far away. We could not now take it back to him, unguessed, unmarked by any spy. And even if we could, soon or late the Lord of the Rings would learn of its hiding place and would bend all his power towards it. Could that power be defied by Bombadil alone? I think not. I think that in the end, if all else is conquered, Bombadil will fall, Last as he was First; and then Night will come."
Wednesday, April 19, 2006
Introducing da Vinci
As we approach the release of "The Da Vinci Code", I wanted to post Schaeffer's analysis of Leonardo's philosophy.
He brings a new factor into the flow of history, and comes closer to being a modern man than any before him. His dates are important (1452-1519), because they overlapped with the beginning of the Reformation. Leonardo da Vinci is also very much a part of a significant shift in philosophic thinking. ... By the time of da Vinci, Neoplatonism was a dominant force in Florence. It became a dominant force for the simple reason that they needed to find some way to put something in the "upper story." They introduced Neoplatonism in an attempt to reinstate ideas and ideals - that is, universals:
Grace - Universals
--------------------
Nature - Particulars
A universal is that which would give meaning and unity to all the particulars. The particulars are all the individual things - each individual thing is a particular.
... Where do you find a unity when you set diversity free? Once the particulars are set free, how do you hold them together? Leonardo grappled with this problem. He was a Neoplatonist painter and, many people have said ... the first modern mathematician. He saw hat if you begin with an autonomous rationality, what you come to is mathematics (that which can be measured), and mathematics only deals with particulars, not universals. Therefore you never get beyond mechanics. As a man who realised the need for a unity, he understood that this would not do. So he tried to paint the soul. The soul in this context is not the Christian soul; the soul is the universal - the soul, for example, of the sea or of the tree.
Soul - Unity
-------------------------------------
Mathematics - Particulars - Mechanics
One of the reasons Leonardo never painted very much was simply that he tried to draw in order to be able to paint the universal. He never succeeded.
A modern writer, Giovanni Gentile, one of the greatest Italian philosophers until his death some years ago, said that Leonardo died in despondency because he would not abandon the hope of a rational unity between the particulars and the universal. To have escaped this despondency, Leonardo would have had to have been a different man. He would have had to let go his hope of unity above and below the line. Leonardo, not being a modern man, never gave up the hope of a unified field of knowledge. He would not, in other words, give up the hope of educated man, who, in the past, has been marked by this insistence on a unified field of knowledge.
Francis Schaeffer: Escape from Reason, Chapter One
Monday, April 17, 2006
Poems for daughters
For Lianne, aged One... and with a gap of fifteen years ...
As far as is possible, stay as you are,
with the eye clear and open
and washed clean of fear,
with the skin untracked
by the sad workings of the heart,
lips unskilled in spite.
As far as possible, stay as you are,
the morning's first light
cause enough for joy,
each passing face
judged only by the colour of its smile.
As far as possible, stay as you are.
Gaze out at the world
with its mystery and noise,
but refuse all offers to join.
Be backwards in evil,
advanced in love.
As far as possible, stay as you are,
with the upturned face
and the open palm,
with the stumble of faith
and the shout of hope.
For of such is the Kingdom.
- Steve Turner
The Original of the Species
Baby slow down
The end is not as fun as the start
Please stay a child somewhere in your heart
I'll give you everything you want
Except the thing that you want
You are the first one of your kind
- Bono/U2
Tuesday, April 11, 2006
More about "Evolve Bots"
(as it is imaginatively titled at the moment - good job I'm not in copywriting!).
It now shows colour gradients for different values of the genes, and mutation doesn't cause it to crash.
Here are some of the things that I hope to do with the program as I continue to work on it.
1) Demonstrate with no selection that bots breed. Done!
2) Then demonstrate natural selection for breedspan. Done! - run several times to compare outcomes.
3) Compare different grid sizes - 10,20,40,80 - compare outcomes/convergence. What is the effect, if any, of different population size on natural selection?
4) Impact of mutation on outcomes/convergence. The proportion of events that have mutations can be controlled, as can the maximum change that a mutation can introduce. Is there an optimum mutation rate that allows development but doesn't wreck existing functionality?
5) Impact of wandering - allow bots to swap places. Does this improve "evolution"?
6) Impact of virility/latency. Currently, a fit individual could spawn several surrounding children every cycle. How about having a limited number of offspring per cycle - or even one offspring per several cycles.
7) Limited evolutionary resources - increasing fitness in one area decreases fitness in other areas.
8) Impact of environment - select for distance from given gene to sum of x and y - and then other more complex interactions.
It now shows colour gradients for different values of the genes, and mutation doesn't cause it to crash.Here are some of the things that I hope to do with the program as I continue to work on it.
1) Demonstrate with no selection that bots breed. Done!
2) Then demonstrate natural selection for breedspan. Done! - run several times to compare outcomes.
3) Compare different grid sizes - 10,20,40,80 - compare outcomes/convergence. What is the effect, if any, of different population size on natural selection?
4) Impact of mutation on outcomes/convergence. The proportion of events that have mutations can be controlled, as can the maximum change that a mutation can introduce. Is there an optimum mutation rate that allows development but doesn't wreck existing functionality?
5) Impact of wandering - allow bots to swap places. Does this improve "evolution"?
6) Impact of virility/latency. Currently, a fit individual could spawn several surrounding children every cycle. How about having a limited number of offspring per cycle - or even one offspring per several cycles.
7) Limited evolutionary resources - increasing fitness in one area decreases fitness in other areas.
8) Impact of environment - select for distance from given gene to sum of x and y - and then other more complex interactions.
Wizards ...
... along the lines of the heroes and villains of earlier posts. I was wondering if anybody had any profound insights into the prevalence of wizards of a particular sort in fiction. We have similar characters in Gandalf and Dumbledore, for example. But you can add to this Merlin and Cadellin ("The Weirdstone of Brisengamen"). In addition to the long beards, there seems to be a shared theme in the fact that they are keen to help the "normal" people, but despite their unusual powers, they need the "universal hero" to fulfil their good purposes.
Is it too easy to imagine that this is a simplified representation of God?
Is it too easy to imagine that this is a simplified representation of God?
Friday, April 07, 2006
Artificial modelling of natural selection
I have been writing a program in Visual Basic (and learning VB as I go along, I hasten to add) which demonstrates natural selection.
The squares are "bots" - digital life, if you will. They have "genes" which encode their sex, the age they reach before they die, the age at which they mature, and the age at which they stop being able to breed. Pink is immature female; red is mature female; maroon is senile female: aqua, blue and navy are the corresponding colours for males. A bot is "born" when an empty space (white) has both a mature female and a mature male in adjacent squares. The genes of a child are copied randomly from its parents. A bot "dies" when its age reaches the maximum age value.
The program is far from perfect yet - I'm pretty sure that it isn't protected against somebody trying to crash it. It's nowhere near Avida (although it's a lot more usable!!). Also, I'd like to develop this further to do some more research, and explore more complex selection processes. But it's a start. And I've been impressed with how much you can do with VB.
The squares are "bots" - digital life, if you will. They have "genes" which encode their sex, the age they reach before they die, the age at which they mature, and the age at which they stop being able to breed. Pink is immature female; red is mature female; maroon is senile female: aqua, blue and navy are the corresponding colours for males. A bot is "born" when an empty space (white) has both a mature female and a mature male in adjacent squares. The genes of a child are copied randomly from its parents. A bot "dies" when its age reaches the maximum age value.The program is far from perfect yet - I'm pretty sure that it isn't protected against somebody trying to crash it. It's nowhere near Avida (although it's a lot more usable!!). Also, I'd like to develop this further to do some more research, and explore more complex selection processes. But it's a start. And I've been impressed with how much you can do with VB.
Wednesday, April 05, 2006
Old Testament Ethnic Cleansing
One of the challenges to Christianity concerns the description in the Old Testament of the complete wiping out of several nations - including women and children. I thought it would make sense to comment on these accounts briefly.
Firstly, in broad terms I agree that you can't read the accounts of "ethnic cleansing" in the Old Testament without finding it shocking. However ...
... those people whom God ordered the Israelites to slaughter in Joshua - did they have the chance to defend themselves? Yes - and it seems unlikely that the population of a city would be less able to defend itself than a nation that had spent 40 years wandering in a desert. Did they have the chance to agree terms with the Israelites? Yes, in many cases. Would they have spared the Israelites had they managed to beat them in combat? Probably not - check out the military behaviour of some of the other nations of the era - no Geneva Convention then. Did God explain why he asked the Israelites to act against the people? Yes. Did God explain why they should be totally destroyed? Yes.
Does anything in these accounts suggest that what happened at that time could be more generally applied to any other historical context? A resounding NO!
Given that God (if he exists) ushers tens of thousands of people out of this life every day, do you think that "normal, everyday" God is less culpable than "special revelation" God? Presumably not.
Given that (according to the Bible) God gives life as and when he chooses, do you not think that it is within his remit also to take it as and when he chooses?
Firstly, in broad terms I agree that you can't read the accounts of "ethnic cleansing" in the Old Testament without finding it shocking. However ...
... those people whom God ordered the Israelites to slaughter in Joshua - did they have the chance to defend themselves? Yes - and it seems unlikely that the population of a city would be less able to defend itself than a nation that had spent 40 years wandering in a desert. Did they have the chance to agree terms with the Israelites? Yes, in many cases. Would they have spared the Israelites had they managed to beat them in combat? Probably not - check out the military behaviour of some of the other nations of the era - no Geneva Convention then. Did God explain why he asked the Israelites to act against the people? Yes. Did God explain why they should be totally destroyed? Yes.
Does anything in these accounts suggest that what happened at that time could be more generally applied to any other historical context? A resounding NO!
Given that God (if he exists) ushers tens of thousands of people out of this life every day, do you think that "normal, everyday" God is less culpable than "special revelation" God? Presumably not.
Given that (according to the Bible) God gives life as and when he chooses, do you not think that it is within his remit also to take it as and when he chooses?
Tuesday, April 04, 2006
An interesting question ...
... now I come to think of it. The Dover School Board that had sought to introduce consideration of some of the weaknesses of evolutionary theory had been elected out of office in November 2005, prior to the judgement (which appeared in December). Given that the new board were elected on a platform of opposition to the new policy on evolution, and that the policy came up for discussion at their first meeting on December 5th, how come the policy wasn't rescinded at that stage?
Monday, April 03, 2006
Busy times
The drier on the washer/drier has stopped working. The baking tin in the breadmaker keeps popping up and stopping the bread from being mixed. The element in one of the ovens broke. The main computer packed in. The boiler stopped working, meaning we have no hot water or heating. All in the space of a couple of weeks. Do you think you could email us some hot water?
In addition, a friend came and stayed with us on his way to Ghana, and another family intends to stay this coming weekend. In addition, the builders on whom we have been waiting for over a year rang last Thursday and said they were ready to start work on our extension - and turned up with equipment on Friday. In addition, I've taken three meetings at our church in 8 days.
The oven is now fixed (I hope!) - I replaced the element with one I got from somebody on eBay. A boiler engineer has been to look at the boiler, and has ordered some more parts (though it looks as though we'll be without water for most of the week - I really hope we'll have it fixed before this other family turns up!!). Most of the computer functionality has been backed onto two other computers.
Some months are easy: some months are harder.
In addition, a friend came and stayed with us on his way to Ghana, and another family intends to stay this coming weekend. In addition, the builders on whom we have been waiting for over a year rang last Thursday and said they were ready to start work on our extension - and turned up with equipment on Friday. In addition, I've taken three meetings at our church in 8 days.
The oven is now fixed (I hope!) - I replaced the element with one I got from somebody on eBay. A boiler engineer has been to look at the boiler, and has ordered some more parts (though it looks as though we'll be without water for most of the week - I really hope we'll have it fixed before this other family turns up!!). Most of the computer functionality has been backed onto two other computers.
Some months are easy: some months are harder.
Sunday, April 02, 2006
What would a real man do?
Amanda pointed me to this post, by Joel, which I enjoyed, and now intend to share with other men of my acquaintance, at least for their discussion. Whilst I approve pretty much of all of what Joel wrote, I am slightly worried about epistemological considerations - he writes, for example, that "God made your skin washable for a reason" - but he doesn't seem to apply this to women.
In the meantime, if anybody is interested in one of the definitive Christian texts on gender, and didn't already know, the entire text of "Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood" by John Piper and Wayne Grudem can be downloaded as a PDF file here (482 pages, 1.4 MB).
In the meantime, if anybody is interested in one of the definitive Christian texts on gender, and didn't already know, the entire text of "Recovering Biblical Manhood and Womanhood" by John Piper and Wayne Grudem can be downloaded as a PDF file here (482 pages, 1.4 MB).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)